search

mathieu-mp / aio-intex-spa

Python client for Intex Spa wifi interface
https://pypi.org/project/aio-intex-spa/
MIT License
17 stars 2 forks source link

Stale temperature when heating (python module) #26

Open montgomeryb opened 1 year ago

montgomeryb commented 1 year ago

I tried looking to see if this is documented elsewhere, but didn't find it. With no heating, it seems the current temperature is correctly reported with the status message, at least it changes over time. However, when the heater is on it doesn't report updated temperatures. I noticed this on the intex app and had to force refresh it to give me an updated temperature. Today after leaving it heating overnight it still had the same temperature. The one way I found to force it to update was by changing the preset_temperature. It seemed that I had to set a different temperature for it to actually update the current temperature.

Am I missing something? I tried the three example get status scripts and info. before trying to change the temperature. Maybe it's my model (SC-WF10)? Anyway, it seems to be working now with making the call to change the preset temperature.

mathieu-mp commented 1 year ago

Hi @montgomeryb,

As you found out, there is an issue opened on the home assistant integration, and I still don't know where the issue does come from.

If possible, could you please provide logs, as I asked Geoff-Hz to ?

I am working on it, and the info you already provided are very useful.

To circumvent the issue, you can automate a 'power on' every few minutes and it might refresh the temperature. But please do not interfere while getting the logs.

Regards

montgomeryb commented 1 year ago

Hi, Thanks for looking into this. The blue line in the image shows when the heating was selected (00:00 - 08:00) and the gold line shows the reported temperature. image intex.log

mathieu-mp commented 1 year ago

Thanks @montgomeryb

This clearly leads to a bug in the spa firmware.

However, the logs confuse me about 2 things:

2023-07-03 08:02:02,529 - intex_spa.intex_spa - INFO - Initializing IntexSpa instance...
2023-07-03 08:02:02,529 - intex_spa.intex_spa - INFO - IntexSpa instance initialized
2023-07-03 08:02:03,030 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: Handling new intent...
2023-07-03 08:02:03,031 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: a spa query is needed
2023-07-03 08:02:03,031 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: new spa query...
2023-07-03 08:02:03,031 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - INFO - Not connected to the spa, trying to connect...
2023-07-03 08:02:03,031 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - DEBUG - Opening TCP connection with the spa at SPA_DEVICE:8990 with asyncio...
2023-07-03 08:02:03,072 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - INFO - TCP connection established with the spa
2023-07-03 08:02:03,073 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - DEBUG - Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16883857230312", "type": 1}'
2023-07-03 08:02:03,187 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - DEBUG - Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16883857230312","data":"FFFF110F0101005F0000008E80808E680000F7","result":"ok","type":2}\n'
2023-07-03 08:02:03,188 - intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status - DEBUG - Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': False, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 95, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}'
2023-07-03 08:02:03,188 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: new status is rendered
2023-07-03 08:02:03,689 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: Handling new intent...
2023-07-03 08:02:03,690 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: a spa query is needed
2023-07-03 08:02:03,690 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: new spa query...
2023-07-03 08:02:03,690 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - DEBUG - Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16883857236907", "type": 1}'
2023-07-03 08:02:03,879 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - DEBUG - Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16883857236907","data":"FFFF110F01010067000000008080806800008C","result":"ok","type":2}\n'
2023-07-03 08:02:03,880 - intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status - DEBUG - Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': False, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}'
2023-07-03 08:02:03,880 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: new status is rendered
2023-07-03 08:02:03,881 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'filter' intent: Handling new intent...
2023-07-03 08:02:03,881 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'filter' intent: triggering a preliminary 'update' intent...
2023-07-03 08:02:03,881 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: Handling new intent...
2023-07-03 08:02:03,884 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: a spa query is needed
2023-07-03 08:02:03,884 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: new spa query...
2023-07-03 08:02:03,885 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - DEBUG - Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16883857238850", "type": 1}'
2023-07-03 08:02:04,013 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - DEBUG - Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16883857238850","data":"FFFF110F01010067000000008080806800008C","result":"ok","type":2}\n'
2023-07-03 08:02:04,014 - intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status - DEBUG - Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': False, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}'
2023-07-03 08:02:04,014 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'status' intent: new status is rendered
2023-07-03 08:02:04,015 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'filter' intent: a spa query is needed
2023-07-03 08:02:04,015 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'filter' intent: new spa query...
2023-07-03 08:02:04,015 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - DEBUG - Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060F010004D4", "sid": "16883857240156", "type": 1}'
2023-07-03 08:02:04,395 - intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer - DEBUG - Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16883857240156","data":"FFFF110F010300670000000082808068000088","result":"ok","type":2}\n'
2023-07-03 08:02:04,396 - intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status - DEBUG - Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}'
2023-07-03 08:02:04,396 - intex_spa.intex_spa - DEBUG - 'filter' intent: new status is rendered

Last thing:

I know am I asking for elaborated tests, but I see you made a great first answer 👍

montgomeryb commented 1 year ago

Thanks @montgomeryb

This clearly leads to a bug in the spa firmware.

However, the logs confuse me about 2 things:

  • The update interval does not comply with the 30-seconds update interval configured in the integration. Did you disable integration auto-update and trigger updates via automation (or else) ?

I am not using Home Assistant (yet) or anything similar. I am using the api in a simple script that is run through cron

  • Heating Stop

    • Did you manually stop heating on the control panel ? I can't read a command to stop heating

Previously I was using the Intex App to schedule the heating from 00:00 - 08:00, it is still active and this time actually worked and turned off the heater.

  • Two status requests [2023-07-03 08:02:03,188 / 2023-07-03 08:02:03,880] are needed to update current_temp to its real value. What would happen if you trigger this heating stop via an automation ?

Last thing:

  • How does the temperature update behaves if you replace your "preset_temp" forced-update automation with a "power on" one ?

I know am I asking for elaborated tests, but I see you made a great first answer 👍 No problem, so I ran the example code 


$ python intex_spa_get_status_with_delay.py
DEBUG:asyncio:Using proactor: IocpProactor
INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:Initializing IntexSpa instance...
INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:IntexSpa instance initialized
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent...
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query...
INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Not connected to the spa, trying to connect...
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Opening TCP connection with the spa at SPA_DEVICE:8990 with asyncio...
INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:TCP connection established with the spa
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885879206834", "type": 1}'
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885879206834","data":"FFFF110F010700650000000080808068000088","result":"ok","type":2}\n'
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 101, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}'
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new status is rendered
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent...
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query...
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885879332107", "type": 1}'
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885879332107","data":"FFFF110F010700650000000080808068000088","result":"ok","type":2}\n'
DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 101, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}'
{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 101, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}
{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 101, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}

Bryan@FuryG8 /cygdrive/d/Dropbox/dev/pitub/intex-spa/examples $ python intex_spa_set_power_on.py DEBUG:asyncio:Using proactor: IocpProactor INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:Initializing IntexSpa instance... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:IntexSpa instance initialized DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: triggering a preliminary 'update' intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Not connected to the spa, trying to connect... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Opening TCP connection with the spa at SPA_DEVICE:8990 with asyncio... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:TCP connection established with the spa DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885879786481", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885879786481","data":"FFFF110F010700650000000080808068000088","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 101, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}' {'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 101, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}

Bryan@FuryG8 /cygdrive/d/Dropbox/dev/pitub/intex-spa/examples $ python intex_spa_set_power_off.py DEBUG:asyncio:Using proactor: IocpProactor INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:Initializing IntexSpa instance... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:IntexSpa instance initialized DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: triggering a preliminary 'update' intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Not connected to the spa, trying to connect... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Opening TCP connection with the spa at SPA_DEVICE:8990 with asyncio... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:TCP connection established with the spa DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885879887174", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885879887174","data":"FFFF110F010700650000000080808068000088","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 101, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new status is rendered DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: new spa query... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060F01400098", "sid": "16885879911919", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885879911919","data":"FFFF110F01000067000000008080806700008E","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': False, 'filter': False, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 103, 'error_code': False}' {'power': False, 'filter': False, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 103, 'error_code': False}

Bryan@FuryG8 /cygdrive/d/Dropbox/dev/pitub/intex-spa/examples $ python intex_spa_set_power_on.py DEBUG:asyncio:Using proactor: IocpProactor INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:Initializing IntexSpa instance... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:IntexSpa instance initialized DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: triggering a preliminary 'update' intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Not connected to the spa, trying to connect... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Opening TCP connection with the spa at SPA_DEVICE:8990 with asyncio... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:TCP connection established with the spa DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885879986360", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885879986360","data":"FFFF110F01000067000000008080806700008E","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': False, 'filter': False, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 103, 'error_code': False}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new status is rendered DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: new spa query... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060F01400098", "sid": "16885880016274", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885880016274","data":"FFFF110F01010067000000008080806700008D","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': False, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '°F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 103, 'error_code': False}' {'power': True, 'filter': False, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 103, 'error_code': False}

I agree that it is more a firmware issue, than this library. I think any command that changes something will force the updated temperature. Turning the power on doesn't do anything as it's already on but turning it off resulted in an update. As I'm sure you noticed, I ran the intex_spa_get_status_double but they both came back with 101 instead of 103.

I was able to try another experiment. I let the tub cool to 102 and turned on the heat. Once the control panel was reading 103 I again rand the status commands. I then went to the app that still had the temperature as 102. I changed the app from Fahrenheit to Celsius. Ran the status and then changed it back to Fahrenheit and the status came back with a current temp of 103. After a short period, I saw the Intext app change from 102 to 103.

I'm not sure how easy it is to capture the traffic to the spa for the unit change and determine the command to send?

$ date |tee -a logfile.txt && python intex_spa_get_status_double.py 2>&1 | tee -a logfile.txt Wed Jul 5 18:06:23 EDT 2023 DEBUG:asyncio:Using proactor: IocpProactor INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:Initializing IntexSpa instance... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:IntexSpa instance initialized DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Not connected to the spa, trying to connect... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Opening TCP connection with the spa at SPA_DEVICE:8990 with asyncio... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:TCP connection established with the spa DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885947838159", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885947838159","data":"FFFF110F010700660000000080808068000087","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 102, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new status is rendered DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885947864089", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885947864089","data":"FFFF110F010700660000000080808068000087","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 102, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new status is rendered {'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 102, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False} {'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 102, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}

Bryan@FuryG8 /cygdrive/d/Dropbox/dev/pitub/intex-spa/examples $ date |tee -a logfile.txt && python intex_spa_get_status_double.py 2>&1 | tee -a logfile.txt Wed Jul 5 18:06:40 EDT 2023 DEBUG:asyncio:Using proactor: IocpProactor INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:Initializing IntexSpa instance... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:IntexSpa instance initialized DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Not connected to the spa, trying to connect... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Opening TCP connection with the spa at SPA_DEVICE:8990 with asyncio... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:TCP connection established with the spa DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885948002950", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885948002950","data":"FFFF110F010700270000000080808028000007","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒C', 'current_temp': 39, 'preset_temp': 40, 'error_code': False}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new status is rendered DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885948027808", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885948027808","data":"FFFF110F010700270000000080808028000007","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒C', 'current_temp': 39, 'preset_temp': 40, 'error_code': False}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new status is rendered {'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒C', 'current_temp': 39, 'preset_temp': 40, 'error_code': False} {'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒C', 'current_temp': 39, 'preset_temp': 40, 'error_code': False}

Bryan@FuryG8 /cygdrive/d/Dropbox/dev/pitub/intex-spa/examples $ date |tee -a logfile.txt && python intex_spa_get_status_double.py 2>&1 | tee -a logfile.txt Wed Jul 5 18:06:48 EDT 2023 DEBUG:asyncio:Using proactor: IocpProactor INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:Initializing IntexSpa instance... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:IntexSpa instance initialized DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Not connected to the spa, trying to connect... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Opening TCP connection with the spa at SPA_DEVICE:8990 with asyncio... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:TCP connection established with the spa DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885948082781", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885948082781","data":"FFFF110F010700670000000080808068000086","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new status is rendered DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885948108396", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885948108396","data":"FFFF110F010700670000000080808068000086","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new status is rendered {'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False} {'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}

Bryan@FuryG8 /cygdrive/d/Dropbox/dev/pitub/intex-spa/examples $ date |tee -a logfile.txt && python intex_spa_set_power_off.py 2>&1 | tee -a logfile.txt Wed Jul 5 18:07:20 EDT 2023 DEBUG:asyncio:Using proactor: IocpProactor INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:Initializing IntexSpa instance... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:IntexSpa instance initialized DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: triggering a preliminary 'update' intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: Handling new intent... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Not connected to the spa, trying to connect... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Opening TCP connection with the spa at SPA_DEVICE:8990 with asyncio... INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:TCP connection established with the spa DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885948409093", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885948409093","data":"","result":"timeout","type":2}\n' INFO:intex_spa.intex_spa:Malformed spa response during spa querying DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new spa query... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060FEE0F01DA", "sid": "16885948494872", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885948494872","data":"FFFF110F010700670000000080808068000086","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': True, 'filter': True, 'heater': True, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'status' intent: new status is rendered DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: a spa query is needed DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: new spa query... DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Sending bytes to the spa: b'{"data": "8888060F01400098", "sid": "16885948496532", "type": 1}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_network_layer:Receiving bytes from the spa: b'{"sid":"16885948496532","data":"FFFF110F01000067000000008080806800008D","result":"ok","type":2}\n' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa_object_status:Spa status: '{'power': False, 'filter': False, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}' DEBUG:intex_spa.intex_spa:'power' intent: new status is rendered {'power': False, 'filter': False, 'heater': False, 'jets': False, 'bubbles': False, 'sanitizer': False, 'unit': '▒F', 'current_temp': 103, 'preset_temp': 104, 'error_code': False}

Bryan@FuryG8 /cygdrive/d/Dropbox/dev/pitub/intex-spa/examples $


P.S. Thanks again for your efforts, and your English is excellent. I had previously tried some hardware attempts at controlling the spa that were not very successful - this is much better even with the Intex quirks.
montgomeryb commented 1 year ago

I think I have found another work-around. Setting the preset-temp to 106 (which is above the maximum) seems to trigger an updated current temperature, and also leaves the preset temp at the existing value.

stale[bot] commented 11 months ago

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

mathieu-mp commented 6 months ago

@montgomeryb, big thanks for the lead!

My spa is disconnected for a while now, and I have currently now way to test the python module by myself. So, could you investigate on these 2 points?

  1. What if we replace all the status requests by the out-of-range target temp setting: when the heater is off, does it enable the heater? Is there any weird behavior altering the current other settings ?
  2. What if the 106 value is provided when the spa is configured in Celsius: does it switch the spa back to Farenheit or does it just discard the out-of-range value and provide the updated current temperature value ?
montgomeryb commented 6 months ago

Hello, you are welcome. Yeah, in Ne York my spa is disconnected for another three months or so :) If there's no answers before then I'll be honoured to help out and get answers for those two questions. Off the top of my head though, I'm pretty sure that if the heater is off and the temperature request is sent it doesn't turn the heater on but reports the current value. I say that I didn't run the heater during the day because electricity rates are much more expensive and I'm pretty sure I still got current temperatures.

gleanlux commented 6 months ago

Hello! Thank you for being active on this topic again!

I'm assembling my SPA this Sunday, and I'd like to help testing it. As soon as I can, I'll do the tests you requested above and post the results.

Have a nice day! :)