mathjax / MathJax-website

The MathJax website
https://www.mathjax.org
22 stars 21 forks source link

update copyright #56

Closed pkra closed 8 years ago

pkra commented 8 years ago

I hear it's 2016.

dpvc commented 8 years ago

I don't think you want to change the copyright year. It is supposed to indicate the date of first publication, not the current date, and establishes how far back your copyright claim extends. If you move this to a later date, then someone else who made a copy in the meantime (say in 2015) can establish their claim to our material as preceding ours. If you want to include 2016 in the date, then I'd recommend using a collection of dates (e.g., 2014,2016) or a range (e.g., 2014-2016). But I would not remove the original date, since that is important.

pkra commented 8 years ago

establishes how far back your copyright claim extends [...] can establish their claim to our material as preceding ours.

Not really since a site owner could set it to whatever they want. This on the other hand is harder to forge. As is this repository, the docs repository etc.

I'd recommend using a collection of dates

Sure. Why not just make a PR?

But I would not remove the original date, since that is important.

The redesign poses some interesting questions on when the content in its current was created.

dpvc commented 8 years ago

Not really since a site owner could set it to whatever they want

Yes, yes, of course someone could set it to whatever they want (and someone in print could do the same), but that is what the date is supposed to indicate, and it gives people looking at the page an idea of the historical extent of the page. I didn't mean "establishes" in the legal sense, as forgery is always possible. I meant that by setting it to 2016, you essentially give up the claim to anything earlier.

I see that you have changed it in a recent commit, which I appreciate.