mathnet / mathnet-numerics

Math.NET Numerics
http://numerics.mathdotnet.com
MIT License
3.44k stars 891 forks source link

Modify NewtonMinimizer so that it forces Hessian to be positive definite #1067

Open strMikhailPotapenko opened 4 months ago

strMikhailPotapenko commented 4 months ago

The current Newton's method implementation has no option to force Hessian to be positive definite, which is a common technique to improve convergence.

In the current implementation the algorithm will not converge to the global minimum if the following conditions are met:

This may not be a complete description of cases when forcing positive definiteness is helpful but I ran into such a case and can illustrate with the Six Camel Hump Function

Below is a contour plot of this function with areas that satisfy the first two requirements above highlighted in dark blue. I have picked some points out of those areas and confirmed that the NewtonMinimizer implementation does not converge when using those points as initial guesses.

image

It would be interesting to write a test that iterates through a grid in the domain above to see if those two conditions are necessary/sufficient for non-convergence but I don't currently have the time and it is outside the scope of this issue.

To restate, an option should be added to NewtonMinimzer that forces the Hessian to be Positive Definite.

I will shortly create a pull request with my proposed solution to this issue.

Regards, Mikhail

strMikhailPotapenko commented 4 months ago

Created and linked a pull request to address this issue. The code changes include a unit test which initializes the NewtonMinimizer at point {1, -0.6} (in one of the blue areas above). If no modification of the Hessian is performed then the algorithm converges to the local maximum of {1.109205317132443, -0.76826824818394157}.