search

mattdibi / redox-keyboard

Ergonomic split mechanical keyboard
MIT License
1.76k stars 163 forks source link

only the side connected with usb cable works #97

Closed schrodinger-s-cat closed 2 years ago

schrodinger-s-cat commented 3 years ago

Issue description: only the side connected with USB cable works, the other side does not work. Both sides works fine when connect with usb cable, the right side keys are mirrored of left though.

Debug done: I checked that the 4.7k ohm resistors are fine. The connection between PD0 of two pro micros checks out, as well as for PD1. After plugged in USB cable, both pro micros are powered and green LEDs light up. I am using the QMK toolbox to flash both side and used the default hex file from the toolbox.

As both sides work fine by themselves, and the connection between PD0 PD1 pins checked out, I am not sure why this does not work. Any ideas? Thank!

yterhorst commented 3 years ago

Hi,

I have also just finished building my redox so this is just a guess. The 4.7k pull-ups are only needed when using I2C which is not configured in the default QMK configuration (so probably neither in the precompiled hex file you are using). Instead the bit bang "serial" driver is used which should be using internal pull-up resistors. I don't see how the lower resistance would cause a problem, but if you want to make sure, you might want to either configure I2C in the firmware or desolder at least the resistor connected to pin 3 / PD0 of the Pro Micro (which is used for the serial connection).

schrodinger-s-cat commented 3 years ago

I tried desolder the resistors and it did not help with the problem. Trying the I2C route at this moment. Actually had the same problem you have in your other post.

mattdibi commented 3 years ago

I suggest you to take a look at the QMK documentation and this troubleshooting guide for the Let's Split keyboard (which uses the same machanism as the Redox for working).

Double check you're not using the infamous Pro Micros described here.

Copying from the Redox documentation:

Pay attention to the Pro Micro you use in this project. Online you can find the infamous Green Pro Micros which have the same pinout of the normal Pro Micro but use a different power circuitry. Being the Redox a split keyboard that relies on detecting which side is directly powered to find which side is the master, these clones are not suited for the task. A more detailed explanation here. Please note that they can come in different colors, not necessarily green.

schrodinger-s-cat commented 3 years ago

Confirmed I am not using the green pro micro. I desoldered the resistors and tried using the default hex file, still does not work. I am going to try the I2C route with 4 10k resistors.

mattdibi commented 3 years ago

@schrodinger-s-cat Also please double check your TRRS cable. It was source of trouble in the past (#77)

schrodinger-s-cat commented 2 years ago

Gave it up after spending some time on it with no solution. Recently I picked it back up and tried a bit more. Found the solution: adding "#define SPLIT_USB_DETECT" to config.h here is what I am using now: config.h.zip

ahpook commented 1 year ago

I had the same issue and the #define SPLIT_USB_DETECT resolved it - is this something that needs to be in the main docs? I am not sure what conditions cause it to be needed.

sidenkov commented 1 year ago

encountered a similar issue. Built a rev1 without rgb, flashed the default layout, only the plugged-in half worked. #define SPLIT_USB_DETECT solved the issue