mautrix / signal

A Matrix-Signal puppeting bridge
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
499 stars 75 forks source link

When I reply to a message, on the signal side an almost useless reference matrix.to URL is given, there is no reply logic, and the reply is not separated with a newline from the quoted message #523

Closed dreirund closed 2 months ago

dreirund commented 2 months ago

I use mautrix-signal version 0.6.2 as installed on yatrix.org in double pupetting mode.

When I reply to a message, on the signal side an almost useless reference matrix.to URL is given, the reply does not appear as a real reply, and the reply is not separated with a newline from the quoted message:

Here is a screenshot the message with the reply as written in the Matrix client:


01_-_reply-matrix


Ans here is how it appears on the Signal side:


02_-_reply-signal


The https://matrix.to/#/![...] url actually confuses people on Signal (I got that feedback).

When I instead reply in thread on the Matrix side, on the Signal side the message appears as a standalone new message:


02_-_reply-thread-signal


When I remove the thread on Matrix side (by removing the "parent" message of the thread, which deletes the whole thread), on Signal side the reply is still present:


04_-_thread-deleted-signal


Regards!

tulir commented 2 months ago

Duplicate of #519