LandingTarget position_valid in python

Y-H-Park commented 2 years ago

This is only bug and feature tracker, please use it to report bugs or request features.

Issue details

We are simulated LandingTarget using mavros, python in Gazebo. Other variables of LandingTarget are used, but, there is no part about the "position_valid". Inputs the position and pose of LandingTarget.pose are good, but it is not working. I wonder if position_valid in python is not suppoted in LandingTarget. I research Auto Drone Station. so, it is very very important for me. Any other solution ?? Thank you!

MAVROS version and platform

Mavros: ?0.18.4? ROS: Melodic Ubuntu: 18.04

Autopilot type and version

[O] ArduPilot [ ] PX4

Version: ?3.7.1?

Node logs


### Diagnostics

header: 
  seq: 24962
  stamp: 
    secs: 0
    nsecs:         0
  frame_id: "map"
target_num: 0
frame: 9
angle: [0.47360944747924805, -0.17104771733283997]
distance: 5.01578426361
size: [1.0, 1.0]
pose: 
  position: 
    x: 2.57066499141
    y: -0.866404584033
    z: 5.01578449959
  orientation: 
    x: 0.0524738328068
    y: -0.00854498640532
    z: 0.985223288658
    w: 0.162814469762
type: 2
"position_valid" : where (?) 
---

vooon commented 2 years ago

https://mavlink.io/en/messages/common.html#LANDING_TARGET https://github.com/mavlink/mavros/blob/ros2/mavros_msgs/msg/LandingTarget.msg

As you can see position_valid if one of mavlink 2 extensions. Likely it does not exist at the moment of plugin development, so it does not exist in ros msg. You should make a PR with that change.

Y-H-Park commented 2 years ago

I wanna use LandingTarget position_valid, I know that in the mavros there is /mavlink/to and /mavlink/from. so can I use the mavlink 2.0 protocol in the mavros ? Thank for quick answer!

vooon commented 2 years ago

It much harder to write decoder around those topics than addition of a few lines of code to existing plugin.

Y-H-Park commented 2 years ago

When using other plugins supported by mavros(vision_pose, setting yaw plugins etc..), are they available at the same time ? Thank you SSSSSSOOOOOOOOOO much!!!!!!

vooon commented 2 years ago

That's the point to have plugins - easiness of addition of custom translators. Plugin may be loaded from third party package, just need to meet some requirements.

Y-H-Park commented 2 years ago

I have a last question... Can I use dronekit with marvos ?

vooon commented 2 years ago

Umm, for what purpose? You can use gcs_url to provide a connection for dronekit.

Y-H-Park commented 2 years ago

I wanna use "Precision Landing" in drone auto station. I am planning to use an ArUco marker on the station, and I need to align the heading. But, you mentioned above, position_valid doesn't exist in the mavros, so it cannot be used. I am searching other way to precision landing on the drone station and align the heading. I can get the drone's axis and ArUco marker's axis. so I wanna use the (landing_target & vision_pose(?)) and (mavros & dronekit(mavlink2.0)) at the same time. Can you recommend other way to adjust marker's position and align marker's orientation at the same time ?

mavlink / mavros