Filmliste context menu (right-click): show complete set of download Urls

mediathekview / MediathekView

Das Programm MediathekView durchsucht die Online-Mediatheken verschiedener Sender

https://mediathekview.de

GNU General Public License v3.0

855 stars 95 forks source link

Filmliste context menu (right-click): show complete set of download Urls #45

Closed Wikinaut closed 9 years ago

Wikinaut commented 9 years ago

Problem

When you have a movie like ARTE "Bob Dylan No Direction Home" (08.08.2015) which is offered in three or more resolutions, the context menu still only allows to copy the "in HD" and "in Klein" kopieren (whatever "Klein" means, the word is a different issue).

Suggestion

I suggest to modify the context menu, or even make it adapting to the movie item, so that the urls for all available resolutions are listed.

As an ad-hoc alternative, change the the download window (the window, where the users selects one of the resolutions for downloading) so that it lists the Urls in addition to the present selection radio buttons.

xaverW commented 9 years ago

it offers all available resolutions

Film-URL kopieren -> in "HD" kopieren -> in "Klein" kopieren

Am Sun, 09 Aug 2015 02:51:30 -0700 schrieb Wikinaut notifications@github.com:

Problem

When you have a movie like ARTE "Bob Dylan No Direction Home" (08.08.2015) which is offered in three or more resolutions, the context menu still only allows to copy the "in HD" and "in Klein" kopieren (whatever "Klein" means, the word is a different issue).

Suggestion

I suggest to modify the context menu, or even make it adapting to the movie item, so that the urls for all available resolutions are listed.

As an ad-hoc alternative, change the the download window (the window, where the users selects one of the resolutions for downloading) so that it lists the Urls in addition to the present selection radio buttons.

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/xaverW/MediathekView/issues/45

Wikinaut commented 9 years ago

No, the current context menu does not offer all three resolutions of that movie, see screenshot

xaverW commented 9 years ago

Film-URL kopieren ---> is the normal resolution
-> in "HD" kopieren ---> is HD
-> in "Klein" kopieren ----> is smaller then the normal resolution

Am Sun, 09 Aug 2015 03:09:53 -0700 schrieb Wikinaut notifications@github.com:

No, the current context menu does not offer all three resolutions of that movie, see screenshot

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/xaverW/MediathekView/issues/45#issuecomment-129150607

Wikinaut commented 9 years ago

Uh, then I suggest now

change

this to a layout which makes this clear:

Film-URL kopieren:
-> "geringe" Auflösung
-> "mittlere" Auflösung
-> "HD" Auflösung

The first entry von mir aus being still linked to medium resolution.

xaverW commented 9 years ago

the "normal" resolution is the best who is not HD,

HD is HD and "klein" ist smaller than the "normal" resolution. Every sender has other resolutions, so there is no "standard" what these exact means (only HD is, what it says)

"Film-URL kopieren" is the normal resolution and exist for every film, the other are optional, that's the reason for the list-sorting.

Am Sun, 09 Aug 2015 03:21:40 -0700 schrieb Wikinaut notifications@github.com:

Uh, then I suggest now

change

this to a layout which makes this clear:
Film-URL kopieren:
-> "geringe" Auflösung
-> "mittlere" Auflösung
-> "HD" Auflösung
The first entry von mir aus being still linked to medium resolution.

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/xaverW/MediathekView/issues/45#issuecomment-129152991

xaverW commented 9 years ago

better?

Am Sun, 09 Aug 2015 03:21:40 -0700 schrieb Wikinaut notifications@github.com:

Uh, then I suggest now

change

this to a layout which makes this clear:
Film-URL kopieren:
-> "geringe" Auflösung
-> "mittlere" Auflösung
-> "HD" Auflösung
The first entry von mir aus being still linked to medium resolution.

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/xaverW/MediathekView/issues/45#issuecomment-129152991

Wikinaut commented 9 years ago

"hoher" vs. "HD" vs. "Klein" -- das passt nicht zusammen.

Was soll das großgeschriebene "Klein" bedeuten? Was soll "HD" (High Definition = "hohe(!) Auflösung") im Gegensatz zu "hoher" ?

Also ich schlage nochmal vor, die Auflösungen eindeutig zu benennen, und die (drei) Texte in einheitlicher Schreibweise zu drucken.

Dazu habe ich meinen obigen Vorschlag auch nochmal überarbeitet. Auf Wunsch mache ich einen formalen Pull-request.

Film-URL kopieren:
-> URL für geringe Auflösung
-> URL für mittlere Auflösung
-> URL für HD-Auflösung

Wikinaut commented 9 years ago

solved via https://github.com/xaverW/MediathekView/commit/abc02cfc8d8a8434ab32b57ab2ae3674d90f9754 . Danke! Bitcoin Donations an welche Adresse?