search

meshtastic / python

The Python CLI and API for talking to Meshtastic devices
https://meshtastic.org
411 stars 172 forks source link

Changing channel preset over admin channel fails on congested networks #662

Closed jonootto closed 2 months ago

jonootto commented 2 months ago

Attempting to set the channel preset over admin channel goes into a loop of requesting channel information which almost inevitably times out in a congested mesh, is this necessary? Could an option be added to skip fetching current config?

meshtastic --host 192.168.1.10 --dest '!xxx' --ch-shortfast Connected to radio Requesting channel 0 info from remote node (this could take a while) Requesting channel 1 info from remote node (this could take a while) Requesting channel 2 info from remote node (this could take a while)

jonootto commented 2 months ago

This was after about 20 attempts where the majority hung on channel 0, none successfully got the point of sending the new config

rcarteraz commented 2 months ago

Attempting to set the channel preset over admin channel goes into a loop of requesting channel information which almost inevitably times out in a congested mesh, is this necessary? Could an option be added to skip fetching current config?

meshtastic --host 192.168.1.10 --dest '!xxx' --ch-shortfast Connected to radio Requesting channel 0 info from remote node (this could take a while) Requesting channel 1 info from remote node (this could take a while) Requesting channel 2 info from remote node (this could take a while)

Can only use --get and --set commands over admin. You’ll need to use --set lora.modem_preset

ianmcorvidae commented 2 months ago

I think those --ch-x commands should be able to work over admin too, but I don't know why they're requesting every channel. I'll need to check if they're doing something other than just setting the preset but hopefully we can disable the channel fetching at least. Until then, using --set is a good idea, since it'll only need to fetch the config for that.

jonootto commented 2 months ago

Thanks folks, confirm the --set option has worked fine, do you want to keep this open to look into the --ch commands?

ianmcorvidae commented 2 months ago

Yeah, I'd like to check on those still. If they're really just setting the preset, maybe we can streamline some stuff. If they're doing more, we should document the differences, so either way let's leave this open, and thanks for the report!