search

metanorma / pubid-nist

BSD 2-Clause "Simplified" License
1 stars 2 forks source link

Issues with revision and edition parsing #126

Closed mico closed 2 years ago

mico commented 2 years ago

From #125

Last part parsed as an edition but not removed from document number:

✅ | NBS CIRC 74-1937e1937 | NBS CIRC 74e1937 | ✅ | NBS.CIRC.74-1937e1937 | NBS.CIRC.74-1937 | Circular of the Bureau of Standards C74: radio instruments and measurements
✅ | NBS HB 44-1988e1988 | NIST HB 44-1988 | ✅ | NBS.HB.44-1988e1988 | NBS.HB.44-1988 | Specifications, tolerances, and other technical requirements for weighing and measuring devices
✅ | NBS IR 84-2946e2946 | NIST IR 84-2946 | ✅ | NBS.IR.84-2946e2946 | NBS.IR.84-2946 | Polymers Division, technical activities 1984
✅ | NBS IR 89-4220e4220 | NIST IR 89-4220 | ✅ | NBS.IR.89-4220e4220 | NBS.IR.89-4220 | Electrical performance tests for storage oscilloscopes
✅ | NBS FIPS 100-1e1 | NIST FIPS 100-1 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.100-1e1 | NBS.FIPS.100-1 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: interface between data terminal equipment (DTE) and
✅ | NBS FIPS 130-1988e1988 | NIST FIPS 130-1988 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.130-1988e1988 | NBS.FIPS.130-1988 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: for information systems - intellig
✅ | NBS FIPS 131-1987e1987 | NIST FIPS 131-1987 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.131-1987e1987 | NBS.FIPS.131-1987 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: small computer system interface (S
✅ | NBS FIPS 132-1987e1987 | NIST FIPS 132-1987 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.132-1987e1987 | NBS.FIPS.132-1987 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: guideline for software verificatio
✅ | NBS FIPS 29-2e2 | NIST FIPS 29-2 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.29-2e2 | NBS.FIPS.29-2 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: interpretation procedures for federal information proces
✅ | NBS FIPS 4-1e1 | NIST FIPS 4-1 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.4-1e1 | NBS.FIPS.4-1 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: representation for calendar date and ordinal date for inform
✅ | NBS FIPS 5-2e2 | NIST FIPS 5-2 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.5-2e2 | NBS.FIPS.5-2 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: codes for the identification of the States, the District of

Edition parsed as edition and revision:

✅ | NIST HB 105-1e1990r1990 | NIST HB 105-1-1990 | ✅ | NIST.HB.105-1e1990r1990 | NIST.HB.105-1-1990 | Specifications and tolerances for reference standards and field standard weights and
✅ | NBS FIPS 100-1e1r1991 | NIST FIPS 100-1-1991 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.100-1e1r1991 | NBS.FIPS.100-1-1991 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: interface between data terminal
✅ | NBS FIPS 11-1eSep1977rSep1977 | NBS FIPS 11-1-Sep1977 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.11-1eSep1977rSep1977 | NBS.FIPS.11-1-Sep1977 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: American nati
✅ | NBS FIPS 14-1eDec1980rDec1980 | NBS FIPS 14-1-Dec1980 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.14-1eDec1980rDec1980 | NBS.FIPS.14-1-Dec1980 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: Hollerith pun
✅ | NBS FIPS 14-1eMay1980rMay1980 | NBS FIPS 14-1-May1980 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.14-1eMay1980rMay1980 | NBS.FIPS.14-1-May1980 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: Hollerith pun
✅ | NBS FIPS 16-1e1977r1977 | NBS FIPS 16-1-1977 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.16-1e1977r1977 | NBS.FIPS.16-1-1977 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: bit sequencing of the code for
✅ | NBS FIPS 17-1e1977r1977 | NBS FIPS 17-1-1977 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.17-1e1977r1977 | NBS.FIPS.17-1-1977 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: character structure and charact
✅ | NBS FIPS 18-1e1977r1977 | NBS FIPS 18-1-1977 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.18-1e1977r1977 | NBS.FIPS.18-1-1977 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: character structure and charact
✅ | NBS FIPS 21-1e1975r1975 | NBS FIPS 21-1-1975 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.21-1e1975r1975 | NBS.FIPS.21-1-1975 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: COBOL
✅ | NBS FIPS 22-1e1977r1977 | NBS FIPS 22-1-1977 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.22-1e1977r1977 | NBS.FIPS.22-1-1977 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: synchronous signaling rates bet
✅ | NBS FIPS 32-1e1975r1975 | NBS FIPS 32-1-1975 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.32-1e1975r1975 | NBS.FIPS.32-1-1975 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: character set for optical chara
✅ | NBS FIPS 32-1e1981r1981 | NBS FIPS 32-1-1981 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.32-1e1981r1981 | NBS.FIPS.32-1-1981 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: character set for optical chara
✅ | NBS FIPS 32-1e1982r1982 | NBS FIPS 32-1-1982 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.32-1e1982r1982 | NBS.FIPS.32-1-1982 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: character sets for optical char
✅ | NBS FIPS 33-1e1974r1974 | NBS FIPS 33-1-1974 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.33-1e1974r1974 | NBS.FIPS.33-1-1974 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: character set for handprinting
✅ | NBS FIPS 68-2eAug1987rAug1987 | NBS FIPS 68-2-Aug1987 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.68-2eAug1987rAug1987 | NBS.FIPS.68-2-Aug1987 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: BASIC
✅ | NBS FIPS 68-2eJan1987rJan1987 | NBS FIPS 68-2-Jan1987 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.68-2eJan1987rJan1987 | NBS.FIPS.68-2-Jan1987 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: programming l
✅ | NBS FIPS 69-1e1985r1985 | NBS FIPS 69-1-1985 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.69-1e1985r1985 | NBS.FIPS.69-1-1985 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: FORTRAN
✅ | NBS FIPS 70-1eJun1986rJun1986 | NBS FIPS 70-1-Jun1986 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.70-1eJun1986rJun1986 | NBS.FIPS.70-1-Jun1986 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: representatio

Part of edition parsed as revision:

✅ | NBS FIPS 107-MAeMar1985r1985 | NBS FIPS 107-Mar1985 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.107-MAeMar1985r1985 | NBS.FIPS.107-Mar1985 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: carrier sense mul
✅ | NBS FIPS 115-MAeMar1985r1985 | NBS FIPS 115-Mar1985 | ✅ | NBS.FIPS.115-MAeMar1985r1985 | NBS.FIPS.115-Mar1985 | Federal Information Processing Standards Publication: information proce
mico commented 2 years ago 
✅ | NBS HB 105-1e1990r1990 | NIST HB 105-1-1990 | ✅ | NBS.HB.105-1e1990r1990 | NBS.HB.105-1r1990 | Specifications and tolerances for reference standards and field standard weights and mea

https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/Legacy/hb/nisthandbook105-1-1990.pdf PubID saying it's edition, but DOI saying it's revision. Inside PDF:

image image

@ronaldtse So is it revision or edition?

ronaldtse commented 2 years ago

@mico great find here! And additionally, it is supposed to be "NIST Handbook" not "NBS Handbook" as per the screenshot! So this is also a data source issue.

In the content, the Abbrev PubID says "Rev. 1990".

Screenshot 2022-01-27 at 11 17 57 AM

So we need to clarify, and I suspect the correct resolution is "Rev. 1990".