metz-theolab / bensira-xml

XML files for the new transcription of the Ben Sira manuscripts by F. Rey.
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
3 stars 0 forks source link

Some superscription #2

Open DavideDAmico04 opened 8 months ago

DavideDAmico04 commented 8 months ago

Here:

https://github.com/metz-theolab/bensira-xml/blob/2f4e16175e28a20e499b8309bd1590a7a61954b1/tei_files/ms_a.xml#L915C34-L915C34

the edition has an ע written at the top of the ל.

we could add these notes in the transcription.

the raw file is okץ

Same issue here:

https://github.com/metz-theolab/bensira-xml/blob/c2c24a64f22276a4c45deb2ea020a1f789ba06d9/tei_files/ms_a.xml#L1039

we miss a superscript "waw" between the "ה" and the "א"

other superscript missing here:

https://github.com/metz-theolab/bensira-xml/blob/c2c24a64f22276a4c45deb2ea020a1f789ba06d9/tei_files/ms_a.xml#L2325

https://github.com/metz-theolab/bensira-xml/blob/2f4e16175e28a20e499b8309bd1590a7a61954b1/tei_files/ms_a.xml#L3827

https://github.com/metz-theolab/bensira-xml/blob/2f4e16175e28a20e499b8309bd1590a7a61954b1/tei_files/ms_a.xml#L3983

https://github.com/metz-theolab/bensira-xml/blob/2f4e16175e28a20e499b8309bd1590a7a61954b1/tei_files/ms_a.xml#L4108

Here, MS A 15:9 is sopralinear and is missing in the tei https://github.com/metz-theolab/bensira-xml/blob/2f4e16175e28a20e499b8309bd1590a7a61954b1/tei_files/ms_a.xml#L4315

In these 2 cases,

https://github.com/metz-theolab/bensira-xml/blob/2f4e16175e28a20e499b8309bd1590a7a61954b1/tei_files/ms_a.xml#L4366C1-L4367C45

https://github.com/metz-theolab/bensira-xml/blob/2f4e16175e28a20e499b8309bd1590a7a61954b1/tei_files/ms_a.xml#L4370

the words בראשית and אדם are splitted in 2 in the trascription becouse of the superlinear addition that are in the raw but not in the tei.

SphRbtHyk commented 8 months ago

Ok, so if I understand correctly, all values that are between in the raw files are missing ?

We need to decide how to take them into account: within the word itself ? the line ?

DavideDAmico04 commented 8 months ago

Yes, the tei is missing some letters/words/phrases superscripted that are there in the raw file instead. I have listed in the comment all the occurrences where this happens in MS A. Yes, later, we will think together about the best solution to insert them. I think we have to think almost on a case-by-case basis because special situations result from the edition.

DavideDAmico04 commented 7 months ago

In MS B

here:

https://github.com/metz-theolab/bensira-xml/blob/0fd903c5f8749156b7d941e4c442e1f56ccaae06/tei_files/ms_b.xml#L66

an entire superscripted line is missing: 6a) [ עבד משכיל חביב כנפש וג [בר