search

mfdz / GTFS-Issues

Documentation and Tracking of Issues in GTFS- and GTFS-RT Feeds
35 stars 3 forks source link

DELFI (VVS): Stuttgarter U-Bahnen als route_type 'straßenbahn' angegeben #139

Open hbruch opened 5 months ago

hbruch commented 5 months ago

Beschreibe den Fehler

Sämtliche U-Bahn-Linien des VVS sind mit route_type == 3 (Bus) angegeben:

"route_id","agency_id","route_short_name","route_long_name","route_type","route_color","route_text_color","route_desc"
"de:vvs:20069_:",7993,"U19","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20019_:",7993,"U19","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20016_:",7993,"U16","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20015_:",7993,"U15","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20014_:",7993,"U14","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20013_:",7993,"U13","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20012_:",7993,"U12","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20011_:",7993,"U11","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20009_:",7993,"U9","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20008_:",7993,"U8","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20007_:",7993,"U7","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20006_:",7993,"U6","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20005_:",7993,"U5","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20004_:",7993,"U4","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20003_:",7993,"U3","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20002_:",7993,"U2","",3,"","",""
"de:vvs:20001_:",7993,"U1","",3,"","",""

Korrekt wäre route_type == 1

Aktualisierungszeitpunkt der GTFS-Daten: 22.1.2024

Downloadlink der GTFS-Daten: Open-Data ÖPNV

hbruch commented 5 months ago

Im heutigen Datensatz werden sie als Straßenbahn (route_type 0) ausgegeben:

"de:vvs:20069_:",7993,"U19","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20019_:",7993,"U19","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20016_:",7993,"U16","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20015_:",7993,"U15","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20014_:",7993,"U14","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20013_:",7993,"U13","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20012_:",7993,"U12","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20011_:",7993,"U11","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20009_:",7993,"U9","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20008_:",7993,"U8","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20007_:",7993,"U7","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20006_:",7993,"U6","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20005_:",7993,"U5","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20004_:",7993,"U4","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20003_:",7993,"U3","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20002_:",7993,"U2","",0,"","",""
"de:vvs:20001_:",7993,"U1","",0,"","",""

In Datensätzen Stand Oktober 2023 waren sie als route_type 1 ausgegeben.

Der VVS veröffentlicht sie übrigens mit dem extended route_type 402 (U-Bahn, ich hätte eher 403 Stadtbahn gewählt, aber das lässt sich diskutieren):

"de:vvs:20001_:","VVS","U1","Fellbach - Hauptbahnhof - Heslach Vogelrain","402","CC9966","000000","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20002_:","VVS","U2","Neugereut - Charlottenplatz - Botnang","402","FF6600","FFFFFF","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20003_:","VVS","U3","Plieningen - Möhringen - Vaihingen","402","804D19","FFFFFF","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20004_:","VVS","U4","Untertürkheim - Charlottenplatz - Hölderlinplatz","402","8368AE","FFFFFF","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20005_:","VVS","U5","Killesberg - Hauptbahnhof - Leinfelden","402","33FFFF","000000","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20006_:","VVS","U6","Gerlingen - Hauptbahnhof - Flughafen/Messe","402","FF00FF","FFFFFF","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20007_:","VVS","U7","Mönchfeld - Hauptbahnhof - Ostfildern","402","66B18C","FFFFFF","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20008_:","VVS","U8","Ostfildern - Degerloch - Vaihingen","402","B3B15F","000000","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20009_:","VVS","U9","Hedelfingen - Hauptbahnhof - Vogelsang (-Botnang)","402","FFD900","000000","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20011_:","VVS","U11","Hauptbahnhof - Berliner Platz - Charlottenplatz - NeckarPark (Stadion)","402","A4A5A5","FFFFFF","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20012_:","VVS","U12","Remseck - Hauptbahnhof - Dürrlewang","402","AFC5E9","000000","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20013_:","VVS","U13","Feuerbach - Bad Cannstatt - Hedelfingen","402","E1ACC0","000000","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20014_:","VVS","U14","Mühlhausen - Charlottenplatz - Vaihingen","402","8EBF4D","000000","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20015_:","VVS","U15","Stammheim - Hauptbahnhof - Ruhbank (- Heumaden)","402","004DFF","FFFFFF","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20016_:","VVS","U16","Giebel - Feuerbach - Bad Cannstatt - Fellbach","402","BAD900","000000","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20019_:","VVS","U19","Neugereut - Bad Cannstatt Wilhelmsplatz - NeckarPark (Stadion)","402","FFB300","000000","VVS_ticketing"
"de:vvs:20069_:","VVS","U19","Bad Cannstatt Wilhelmsplatz - NeckarPark (Stadion)","402","A4A5A5","FFFFFF","VVS_ticketing"

Was beim direkten Vergleich zudem auffällt: In der Datenweitergabe-Transformations-Kette gehen leider Angaben wie route_long_name, route_color, route_text_color verloren...

BeckertAnke commented 5 months ago

Der DELFI-Export kennt leider keine Stadtbahn, sondern nur Straßenbahnen und U-Bahnen als Verkehrsmittel. Daher gab es Unklarheiten, was auszuwählen ist. Für den nächsten Export ändern wir es wieder auf U-Bahn.

Viele Grüße Anke Beckert (DELFI-Team)

hbruch commented 5 months ago

Hallo Anke Beckert! Vielen Dank für die Info und die angekündigte Umstellung. Wenn der DELFI-Export keine Stadtbahn kennt, bedeutet dies, dass nicht das gesamte Spektrum an "quasi-Standard" extended route_types genutzt werden kann?

BeckertAnke commented 5 months ago

Hallo Holger Bruch, derzeit wird nur die Standard-Liste und nicht die Extended-Liste der route_types umgesetzt.

Viele Grüße Anke Beckert (DELFI-Team)