search

mfdz / GTFS-Issues

Documentation and Tracking of Issues in GTFS- and GTFS-RT Feeds
35 stars 3 forks source link

DELFI (VMT, bodo,VGN): Busverkehre als Schienenverkehre angegeben #144

Closed hbruch closed 1 month ago

hbruch commented 2 months ago

Beschreibe den Fehler Im aktuellen GTFS-Datensatz werden Busverkehre des VMT als Regionalzug (route_type=106) angegeben:

grep ,106, routes.txt

...
"de:VMT:16068009|Bus|111|111|EVAGBus:_106",11742,"111","",106,"54AB26","FFFFFF",""
"de:VMT:16062041|Bus|311|K|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"K","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062041|Bus|307|G|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"G","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062041|Bus|305|E|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"E","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062041|Bus|301|A|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"A","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062066|Bus|293|293|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"293","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062066|Bus|292|292|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"292","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16065067|Bus|291|291|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"291","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062063|Bus|29|29|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"29","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062037|Bus|282|282|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"282","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062037|Bus|281|281|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"281","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062037|Bus|28|28|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"28","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16061117|Bus|272|272|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"272","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062062|Bus|271|271|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"271","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16061116|Bus|27|27|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"27","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062062|Bus|262|262|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"262","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062041|Bus|261|261|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"261","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062041|Bus|26|26|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"26","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062062|Bus|251|251|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"251","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062062|Bus|25|25|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"25","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062005|Bus|241|241|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"241","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062005|Bus|24|24|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"24","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062036|Bus|231|231|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"231","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:03153016|Bus|23|23|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"23","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062008|Bus|21|21|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"21","",106,"","",""
"de:VMT:16062008|Bus|20|20|NDH_Bus:_106",13429,"20","",106,"","",""
...

Aktualisierungszeitpunkt der GTFS-Daten 22.04.2024

Downloadlink der GTFS-Daten Open-Data ÖPNV

hbruch commented 2 months ago

Ebenso sind mit dem o.g. Datensatz einige Buslinien des Busunternehmens Schnappinger, insbesondere im Landkreis Landsberg am Lech, fälschlicherweise als "railway service" (route_type=100) angegeben.

$ grep 13586 routes.txt | grep 100
"6135792_100",13586,"913","",100,"","",""
"6135791_100",13586,"912","",100,"","",""
"6135790_100",13586,"221","",100,"","",""
"6135789_100",13586,"141","",100,"","",""
"6135785_100",13586,"31","",100,"","",""
"6135784_100",13586,"22","",100,"","",""
"6135783_100",13586,"21","",100,"","",""
"6135782_100",13586,"14","",100,"","",""
BeckertAnke commented 2 months ago

Danke für den Hinweis. Sowohl für dem VMT als auch für Schnappinger sind die Verkehrsmittel korrigiert worden und sollten mit dem nächsten Datensatz korrekt als Bus kommen.

Anke Beckert (DELFI Wirkbetrieb)

hbruch commented 2 months ago

Danke für die schnelle Rückmeldung. Ich lasse den Eintrag noch offen, bis der nächste Datensatz bereitsteht.

hbruch commented 2 months ago

Im Datensatz vom 29.4.2024 sind weiterhin die folgenden zwei mutmaßlichen Buslinien des VMT als Regionalbahn (route_type=106) bzw. Straßenbahn (route_type=900)angegeben:

"de:VMT:16068009|Bus|111|111|EVAGBus:_106",11742,"111","",106,"54AB26","FFFFFF",""
"de:VMT:16068009|Bus|111|111|EVAGBus:_900",11742,"111","",900,"54AB26","FFFFFF",""

Darüberhinaus sind im aktuellen Datensatz diese beiden Linien des VGN als S-Bahnen (route_type=109) angegeben, obwohl es sich um Buslinien handeln dürfte:

"de:vgn:700_1874:0_109",14452,"1874","",109,"","",""
"de:vgn:700_1861:0_109",14452,"1861","",109,"","",""

Und auch bei diesen Linien des Stadtverkehr Friedrichshafen handelt es sich um Bus- und nicht wie angegeben S-Bahn-Linien:

"de:bodo:17SBF_:_109",14422,"SBF","",109,"","",""
"de:bodo:17E16_:_109",14422,"E16","",109,"","",""
"de:bodo:17011_:_109",14422,"11","",109,"","",""
"de:bodo:17010_:_109",14422,"10","",109,"","",""
"de:bodo:17005_:_109",14422,"5","",109,"","",""
"de:bodo:17002_:_109",14422,"2","",109,"","",""
"de:bodo:17001_:_109",14422,"1","",109,"","",""
BeckertAnke commented 2 months ago

Folgende Korrekturen sind im Datensatz vom 06.05. enthalten: Die beiden VGN-Linien haben 'route_type=3'. Die Linien vom Stadtverkehr Friedrichshafen haben 'route_type=700'

Leider noch nicht korrigiert werden konnten die Verkehrsmittel der Linie de:VMT:16068009|Bus|111|111|EVAGBus: Ziel ist die Korrektur bis zur nächsten Woche.

Anke Beckert (DELFI Wirkbetrieb)

hbruch commented 1 month ago

Die gemeldeten Fehler sind im Datensatz vom 13.5.2024 behoben. Vielen Dank @BeckertAnke !