Esad-np
commented
4 months ago here is the example same song from Qobuz and tidal: [24-03-17 15:22:56.7167] Plugins::Qobuz::ProtocolHandler::trackGain (185) { artist => { albums_count => 18, id => 520_907, image => undef, name => "Psychic Ills", picture => undef, slug => "psychic-ills", }, duration => 2454, genre => "Alternative & Indie", genres_list => [ "Pop/Rock", "Pop/Rock\x{2192}Rock", "Pop/Rock\x{2192}Rock\x{2192}Alternatif et Ind\xE9", ], goodies => [], id => "0616892178866", image => "https://static.qobuz.com/images/covers/66/88/0616892178866_600.jpg", isClassique => 0, label => "Sacred Bones Records", labelId => 100_056, media_count => 1, parental_warning => bless(do{(my $o = 0)}, "JSON::XS::Boolean"), release_type => "album", replay_gain => "-11.43", replay_peak => 1, title => "Hazed Dream", year => 2011, } [24-03-17 15:22:56.7168] Plugins::Qobuz::ProtocolHandler::trackGain (188) Using album gain value of -11.43 : 1 for track: Mind Daze [24-03-17 15:22:56.7169] Plugins::Qobuz::ProtocolHandler::trackGain (192) Net replay gain: -11.43 [24-03-17 15:23:03.5913] Plugins::TIDAL::API::Async::ANON (430) Getting /tracks/19329987/playbackinfopostpaywall?assetpresentation=FULL&audioquality=HI_RES&countryCode=GB&limit=100&playbackmode=STREAM [24-03-17 15:23:03.5921] Plugins::TIDAL::ProtocolHandler::getNextTrack (197) Getting next track playback info for tidal://19329987.flc [24-03-17 15:23:03.7781] Plugins::TIDAL::API::Async::ANON (439) { albumPeakAmplitude => 1, albumReplayGain => "-11.43", assetPresentation => "FULL", audioMode => "STEREO", audioQuality => "LOSSLESS", bitDepth => 16, manifestMimeType => "application/vnd.tidal.bts", sampleRate => 44_100, trackId => 19_329_987, trackPeakAmplitude => 1, trackReplayGain => "-11.43", }
When I play them, the web interface only shows the ReplayGain for Qobuz track but no ReplayGain is shown for Tidal track
michaelherger
Great work on the tidal plugin so far guys! Please share/provide the donation link ...
Issue: playing tidal songs via LMS is very loud and I think this is because the ReplayGain is not retrieved from tidal. I checked few songs from Tidal and same songs from Qobuz and loudness difference is incredible. As far as I can tell this is only because Qobuz plugin handles correctly the ReplaiGain (Track and Album) ...