mickelus
commented
5 years ago I agree with you! The initial plan was for all crafting in tetra to be sort of minigames done ingame with the assistance of in-world UI hints, but that proved difficult and i settled with a regular UI for now ™.
I've been playing around with something similar to how "coordinate crafting" works in wildstar https://youtu.be/RVEFwFP_-hk?t=565.
E.g.
- player provides some material
- player clicks a UI representation of the module that is to be repaired with tools from their inventory
- each click fills up a repair progress bar
- there's a limited amount of clicks before they need to provide more materials
- where the player clicks affects how much progress is gained and how much bonus durability is provided
- tool type, tier & effects could affect progress and durability bonus
- different modules and variants would have different patterns for how much progress & durability bonus is gained, making some variants more difficult to repair and the player would learn and become more efficient over time
- there's preferrably something in common between all variants of a module: if I'm good at repairing iron hilts I would have a good starting point for repairing copper hilts
- there's preferrably something in common between one variant of different modules: if I'm good at repairing iron hilts I would have a good starting point for repairing iron blades
As you've said, repairing has the potential to be a fun experience and it also has lots of potential to affect the dynamics of the modular item systems. If you have any ideas feel free to pitch in!
The current solution is based on the durability of the modules, but it randomizes the durability gained and the number of materials required for each attempt (between 30-100%). As a first step towards improving this I'll try fixing the amount to 100% of the modules durability and material cost for all repair attempts.
Edulml
Feature Request
Feature description
Repairing, currently, is kind of repetitive. While I praise Tetra's modularity and boldness, I'm not satisfied with how repairing is currently handled. I think we could do better. I'm not saying scrap the current system entirely, but we could make improvements. I don't have anything too specific in mind, but I'm happy to let this be a "brainstorming" thread. So, I'll start a list of complaints I have offhand, with some possible ideas to help alleviate:
Now, I think we could change a couple things around to make the system more streamlined. Personally, materials should repair more globally. Nobody likes using 5+ diamonds to repair a pickaxe; however, statically increasing this value could prove uninteresting. Something that I think would tackle both points on the above list is perhaps a repair "minigame." Nothing too complex. Something where you give it a material, and you have to perform some form of simple action to repair. The amount repaired will vary based on how well the player does. Perhaps the player could also get a bonus for enchantments on the tool used to repair.
Another thing to consider is giving each "part" of the tool its own durability. However, this could prove too complicated, and cloud up what I think is honestly a pretty charming simplicity.
How it improves the player experience
I think this would improve the general flow of the game. In the earlygame, I tend to use stone tools for as long as I can get away with it. You have to repair those frequently, and with the current system, it can take up to 20+ mouse clicks in the same GUI just to get to full durability. Not only that, making repairing an "enjoyable" experience will help prevent players from being annoyed when their tools break, and possibly even look forward to it, just to repair them. Odd, right?
Tetra synergies
Honestly, I don't have a lot for this section. Making the minigames based on each tool you use to repair each given part would make sense, right? Right. That's all I've got.