microbiomedata / nmdc-metadata

Managing metadata and policy around metadata in NMDC
https://microbiomedata.github.io/nmdc-schema/
Other
2 stars 0 forks source link

metadata error - deep marine marked as coastal #279

Open cmungall opened 3 years ago

cmungall commented 3 years ago
             lat_lon: 33.0 -118.0
     env_broad_scale: ENVO:00002030
env_broad_scale_labe: aquatic biome
     env_local_scale: ENVO:00002450
env_local_scale_labe: ocean basin
          env_medium: ENVO:00002113
    env_medium_label: deep marine sediment
        geo_loc_name: USA: California
     collection_date: 2015-06-19
           ecosystem: Environmental
  ecosystem_category: Aquatic
      ecosystem_type: Marine
   ecosystem_subtype: Coastal
  specific_ecosystem: Sediment
               depth: 860.0 m
            add_date: 21-MAY-17 11.27.12.558000000 AM
           community: enriched cells
             habitat: marine sediment
          identifier: Roland_Nextera1
            location: Santa Monica Basin, California, USA
            mod_date: 18-JUN-19 04.41.31.672000000 PM
  ncbi_taxonomy_name: marine sediment metagenome
sample_collection_si: marine basin floor

is ecosystem_subtype correct? Is there a definition for the gold term 'Coastal'?

dwinston commented 3 years ago

There are several /Environmental / Aquatic / Marine / \w+ / Sediment/ classification paths in GOLD, including Coastal. When I enter "deep marine sediment basin" into this path search tool I built, I see a "Marine basin floor" ecosystem_subtype, which matches the sample_collection_si field above, so it seems that would be more suitable than Coastal in this case?

TBKReddy commented 3 years ago

Reported biosample now showing marine basin floor as the ecosystem subtype. All other biosamples under this study have marine basin floor (or other relevant values) and none showing coastal for ecosystem subtype anymore. https://gold.jgi.doe.gov/biosamples?page=1&Study.GOLD+Study+ID=Gs0133461&Study.Relevance.ID_options=or&Biosample.Ecosystem+Type=Marine&count=500&desc=Biosample.Ecosystem+Subtype

@Jagadish Chandrabose Sundaramurthi check this out and close it. Looks like this has been taken care of on or around Feb 22nd.