microdotblog / issues

42 stars 0 forks source link

External reply post incorrectly tagging someone mentioned in the post #265

Open gRegorLove opened 3 months ago

gRegorLove commented 3 months ago

This one is kind of odd, will do my best to describe what I think happened:

Describe the problem:

Tracy's article originally had microformats2 in-reply-to this Substack article.

Her post included links to other posts, like this one which is a mb-powered site. Tracy's site sent Webmentions, so the mb webmention endpoint received that. It appears mb incorrectly interpreted it as a direct reply (instead of a mention). In the conversation view, mb shows: @petebrown: followed by the contents of her article, sans the title.

This gave the appearance of Tracy replying to Pete's conversation with a lengthy post, which it wasn't.

After this happened, she removed the in-reply-to and changed it to a quotation post in attempt to remove it from the mb conversation view.

What I would expect to happen:

Either skip webmentions where the mb URL is not in the in-reply-to, or show it as a short [name] mentioned this [link].