search

microsoft / Open-Maps

Microsoft Open Data Team
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
132 stars 13 forks source link

Road Editing in Peru #58

Open LeeKana opened 4 years ago

LeeKana commented 4 years ago

Edición de carreteras en Perú

Descripción del Proyecto:

Este proyecto busca a mejorar los datos de mapas en Perú. Usaremos todos los recursos de imaginería aérea y imágenes a nivel de calle disponibles en OSM. Planeamos editar las carreteras enfocado en lo siguiente:

Podríamos editar algunas otras características del mapa, como cuerpos de agua, características naturales, características de uso de la tierra y edificios.

Procesaremos esto de acuerdo con OSM, las pautas locales y cumpliendo con los directrices de edición organizada.

Pautas de Mapeo:

Cuando sea posible, agregaremos y actualizaremos las características de las carreterras enfocado en lo siguiente:

El equipo seguirá las pautas de OSM al agregar y etiquetar características del mapa.

Área de Enfoque:

Este será un esfuerzo a nivel nacional en Perú.

Comentarios en Conjuntos de Cambios:

El equipo agregará comentarios en conjuntos de cambios que sigan las pautas de conjuntos de cambios de OSM

Detección de Errores:

Usaremos el validador de JOSM para buscar errores, siguiendo el wiki y las pautas de LearnOSM.

Información adicional:

Para cualquier pregunta, comentario o preocupación, no dude en enviar un correo electrónico al equipo a openmaps(at)Microsoft.com.

LeeKana commented 4 years ago

Task description:

In this task, we intend to improve the map data in Peru. We will also use all available aerial and street level imagery assets available in OSM. We intend to edit the roads, looking to focus the following:

We will also add or improve road relations, such as turn restrictions or destination signs.

Additionally, we may edit some other map features such as water bodies, natural features, landuse features, and buildings.

We will be processing this according to OSM, the local guidelines, and adhering to the Organized editing guidelines.

Mapping Guidelines:

We will be adding/updating (when possible):

The team will follow OSM guidelines for adding and tagging each.

Area of Focus:

This will be a country wide effort across Peru.

Changeset Comments:

The team will be adding changeset comments that follow OSM changeset guidelines.

Error Detection:

We will use the validator in the JOSM tool to look for errors, following the wiki as well as the LearnOSM guidelines.

Additional Info:

For any questions, comments, concerns, feel free to email the team at openmaps(at)Microsoft.com.

erickdeoliveiraleal commented 4 years ago

As I did for Venezuela, I created notes to help them identify missing roads: http://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-notes-country?c=Peru&limit=no. I used JOSM and downloaded state by state and compared with imagery to identify missing roads.

LeeKana commented 4 years ago

Thank you for identifying these missing roads Erick! We will work to add missing roads and resolve these map notes in Peru as well.

ovruni commented 4 years ago

Hello, I have noticed in Piura several street crossings with buildings, in the same way I just saw in Huaral a barrier crossing with a street. Please avoid these street crossings when adding streets in Peru. You can use https://osmose.openstreetmap.fr to see the objects overlap.

BrackoNe commented 4 years ago

Hello, thanks for the post.

Please send exact samples for further investigation. If there is a barrier and you have a local knowledge, please feel free to add a proper barrier on a node of the highway.

ovruni commented 4 years ago

Here are some that I just found

Sullana way 707870466 way 874693174

Catacaos way 532326293 way 863865787

Lambayeque way 666163227 way 91014053

Puente Piedra way 292232424 way 872866003

BrackoNe commented 4 years ago

Here are some that I just found

Sullana way 707870466 way 874693174

Catacaos way 532326293 way 863865787

Lambayeque way 666163227 way 91014053

Puente Piedra way 292232424 way 872866003

Thank you so much for the quick response and for sharing such great examples!

We are aligning a network to the existing network, and even though we are trying to avoid such cases, sometimes it is not possible at all since the geometry of the buildings isn't exact, but the approximation of the footprint.

There are such bad cases like you've shared: image

We will try to avoid making new logical issues in the future, but it would be great if the community can organize a mapathlon and fix such irregular buildings. We are aligning the road network to the existing one, so we are very often unable to avoid such crossings since whoever done building footprints, haven't check whether aerial imagery is aligned to the road network before they have started tracing the footprints.

Thanks once again, Nemanja

sanderd17 commented 4 years ago

How will you alter road alignment? Peru has a very rough terrain, which gives issues with imagery alignment. All imagery sources I've found so far had alignment issues. You could align it on one position, but a few 100m further, it would start to deviate.

Even GPS is often imprecise next to cliffs and under trees.

I don't think bad alignment is a huge issue. If the relative alignment is correct, and features get named, this already give a whole lot of valuable information on the map. But I would refrain from aligning complete street layouts to a certain imagery source.

BrackoNe commented 4 years ago

I completely agree with you on this, this is why we are aligning on micro location if it is necessary.

erickdeoliveiraleal commented 3 years ago

Updated link: http://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-notes-country-custom?c=Peru&query=open