search

microsoft / PowerToys

Windows system utilities to maximize productivity
MIT License
109.49k stars 6.45k forks source link

Mouse Without Borders "Use Service" disconnects Win 10 client from cross-border mousing #26147

Open stevemagruder opened 1 year ago

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

Microsoft PowerToys version

0.70.0

Installation method

PowerToys auto-update

Running as admin

Yes

Area(s) with issue?

Mouse Utilities

Steps to reproduce

  1. Set up Windows 11 system to use Mouse Without Borders as a "director", for lack of a better word. As part of this, set new security key that the Windows 10 system "client" will connect to.
  2. Run MWB as a service on the Win 11 (director) system.
  3. Set up Win 10 system on same network to use MWB as a client. Connect to Win 11 system's (director) key. Mousing across the screens work as expected.
  4. Run MWB as a service on the Win 10 (client) system. It gets outlined in red on the director system, and it can't be moused to from the Win 11 (director).
  5. Activate my hard switch to use Win 10 system, and stop running MWB as a service - now mousing between systems works again.

✔️ Expected Behavior

Running MWB as a service on the Win 10 client shouldn't have stopped the cross-border mousing capability. (Or should it have? Am I missing something?)

❌ Actual Behavior

Cross-border mousing stopped working per step 4 above.

Other Software

Windows 11 Home 22H2 Build 22621.1776 (director) Windows 10 Home 22H2 Build 19045.3030 (client)

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

By the way, thank you for this great tool. It's working well enough so that I could uninstall a dedicated app that was giving me even worse issues.

yuyoyuppe commented 1 year ago

Hi @stevemagruder, thank you for the report! MWB clients should work in all combinations of service/non-service. I have a similar setup as you (win 10 laptop + win 11 desktop) and couldn't reproduce your issue. Can you please try:

The red outline means that the keys are not matched.

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

OK, here's the steps I took:

  1. MWB working when directly connected to Win11 laptop and mousing to Win10 laptop.
  2. Hard switched from Win11 laptop to Win10 laptop. (MWB still working)
  3. Turned Use Service On. (MWB no longer working)
  4. Connect to security key and pc name I was already supposedly connecting to. (MWB now working again)
  5. Hard switched from Win10 laptop to Win11 laptop. (MWB still working)

OK, so it's now in a state where it's all working. But isn't it peculiar that turning Use Service on would knock out MWB like this, even if re-connectable?

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

By the way, my Windows versions have changed since the original report: Windows 11 Home 22H2 Build 22621.1778 (director laptop) Windows 10 Home 22H2 Build 19045.3031 (client laptop)

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

Also, I wanted to note a kind of side issue that I'm not sure is worthy to split into its own. Before successfully running as a service on the Win10 laptop, and I was hard-connected to my Win11 laptop - whenever I moused over to install an app on the Win10 laptop, and the UAC window popped up, MWB stopped working. But now that MWB is running as a service on Win10, that problem stopped happening.

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

Unfortunately, keeping this running as a service on Win10 isn't something I can keep stable. I've had to roll back my Win10 laptop to not running this as a service.

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

whenever I moused over to install an app on the Win10 laptop, and the UAC window popped up, MWB stopped working

I'm going to log this as a separate issue, as there's an issue every time UAC pops up.

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

I just added a third device, this time another Win 11 laptop with the same version of Windows as the first (director) device. I was able to run MWB as a service on that with no issue. So, this seems to be a Windows 10-related issue. No matter what I try, I can't get the service to work on the Win 10 laptop.

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

I've poked around a bit and from a couple sources, it appears MWB uses .NET Framework 4.0. The version of that on my Win11 laptops is 4.8.09032 and on the Win10 laptop, it's 4.8.04084. Might this be something to consider?

yuyoyuppe commented 1 year ago

Thanks for the additional info, we'll look into it.

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

I eliminated one possible cause. I upgraded to a Wi-Fi 6 / Wireless-AX card on the Windows 10 laptop. Doing that fixed random network drops, likely owing to now using a device driver for wireless that's around a month old compared to 4 years old before. Unfortunately, this upgrade did nothing to change the outlines of the above described problem.

xBlueSoulx commented 1 year ago

Hi @stevemagruder, thank you for the report! MWB clients should work in all combinations of service/non-service. I have a similar setup as you (win 10 laptop + win 11 desktop) and couldn't reproduce your issue. Can you please try:

  • connecting to the director machine again using the "Connect" button
  • restarting PowerToys on both machines
  • pressing "Refresh connections"

The red outline means that the keys are not matched.

Thanks, this just solved my issue!

stevemagruder commented 1 year ago

Doing what I've already done per the same instructions above won't be of assistance. Thanks anyway.