search

microsoft / WindowsAppSDK

The Windows App SDK empowers all Windows desktop apps with modern Windows UI, APIs, and platform features, including back-compat support, shipped via NuGet.
https://docs.microsoft.com/windows/apps/windows-app-sdk/
MIT License
3.85k stars 326 forks source link

Get rid of the WinUI 3 Windows Runtime Component template for C++ #1646

Open JaiganeshKumaran opened 3 years ago

JaiganeshKumaran commented 3 years ago

Consider removing the WinUI 3 Windows Runtime Component template for C++ since one can just as easily use the old templates shipped in VS for C++/CX and the extension for C++/WinRT and reference WinUI 3 and WindowsAppSDK if they wanted to. There's too many templates in VS already and this just adds more bloat. The C# one could remain as it targets a different runtime altogether which makes it less of a good choice for most libraries as they would want to support all kinds of apps possible.

roxk commented 3 years ago

But WinUI3's C++ templates just added WIL include and package reference, so technically they are not the same as those in C++/CX or C++/WinRT.

JaiganeshKumaran commented 3 years ago

But WinUI3's C++ templates just added WIL include and package reference, so technically they are not the same as those in C++/CX or C++/WinRT.

That's right but if the developers want it, they can add it manually. Unlike the app templates, the component doesn't really contain any code. There shouldn't be a reason for a duplicated template that has nothing but some NuGet references.

sylveon commented 2 years ago

The Windows Runtime Component template for WinUI 3 supports being compiled targetting the desktop API set, and uses the WinUI 3 XAML compiler instead of the system XAML compiler

JaiganeshKumaran commented 2 years ago

The Windows Runtime Component template for WinUI 3 supports being compiled targetting the desktop API set, and uses the WinUI 3 XAML compiler instead of the system XAML compiler

It could be implemented in a wizard-like fashion instead of being bloated up with too many similar templates. And having a Runtime Component template for a UI framework is wierd.