Closed JobLeonard closed 3 years ago
Thanks for the response! I honestly haven't found that the /l to feel really 'out of slope' with the other letters, but I'll take another look at it.
The /r in particular is really challenging because without that little bit sticking up on the top left, it can be mistaken for an /n at a glance. But then it makes the letter feel taller, especially if the top right part of the /r is at the x-height. So there's a degree of balance there. These cursive forms can be surprisingly tough!
I really dig the new cursive styles. Great job to everybody involved.
That said, I tend to agree with @JobLeonard . I think the lowercase L could have just a wee bit more slant. The lowercase Y seems more or less ok IMO.
Thanks a lot for considering these remarks and a huge thanks again for the lovely job done on the font! :heart:
Check whether if fontname is set like this. That helped me Before the fix
@genesi5: was your reply meant to go below #468, where people explicitly ask for a non-cursive font version?
If not: I'm seeing the cursive variant glyphs just fine, I'm just nitpicking a bit on the style of an individual one (but the attempt to help is still appreciated!)
Environment
Steps to reproduce
Expected behavior
A consistent slant for every glyph (except for block glyphs and similar "graphic" ones)
Actual behavior
I will use this screenshot of a doc comment to illustrate:
In an attempt to highlight the differences in perceived slants I added vertical pipes between the lines, while forcing my editor to use a small line height.
So first of all, I want to acknowledge that this is somewhat subjective, and that I might be alone in "reading" these glyphs this way. Having said that, to me the cursive lowercase L feels almost straight. The other glyphs appear to "align" with the slanted vertical pipe characters above and below their lines (although the lowercase Y also appears a bit less slanted than the rest of the glyphs, but it's not as jarring).
I know this is very nitpicky, and I don't want to criticize the designers of the cursive set - I think their design is cute overall, and I'm aware that font design is an art as much as a science, and more importantly that it's an incredible hassle to get it to "feel" just right. However, when quickly skimming text any cursive L's in the text really stand out a lot to me, kind of like how a single bold glyph among non-bold glyphs would stand out. They don't "disappear" into the whole word but break into individual characters, if that makes sense. And I think it's largely because of this difference in (perceived) slant.
(on a similar note the lowercase R breaks with the x-height in a way that makes
dendrogram
read a bit "wobbly", but that's probably overdoing the nitpicking)