search

microsoft / fhir-server

A service that implements the FHIR standard
MIT License
1.15k stars 492 forks source link

Chained search return an error about multiple resource type, even if only 1 is possible (patient.identifier) #3839

Open Thopap opened 2 months ago

Thopap commented 2 months ago

Describe the bug While playing around using this FHIR Server as a backend to a XDS Registry, is was observed that the handling of chained parameters seems cause a unexepcted behavior. Resource "DocumentReference" contain a search parameter "patient" which is already restricted by the spec to the Patient resource. When using a chained search here (e.g. "patient.identifier"), the MS FHIR Server complain about "multiple" possible resource types on this search paramter. Other FHIR Server like Hapi or Firely work as expected.

FHIR Version? R4

Version used Docker image from "mcr.microsoft.com/healthcareapis/r4-fhir-server" (4.0.128)

Data provider? SQL Server

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Trigger a FHIR Query on DocumentReference resource with a chained search parameter, e.g. /DocumentReference?patient.identifier=urn%3Aoid%3A2.999.1.2.3.4%7CIPF-1714920157063

Expected behavior SearchResponse is successful and return the expected results.

Current workaround Use a chained search with explicit resource type definition, e.g. "patient:Patient.identifier" instead of "patient.identifier"

Actual behavior Server response with a http 403 containing the following error message: <?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><OperationOutcome xmlns="http://hl7.org/fhir"><id value="ef85d13d-804b-4074-87d3-3a92c19640a8" /><meta><lastUpdated value="2024-05-05T14:42:39.4336098+00:00" /></meta><issue><severity value="error" /><code value="invalid" /><diagnostics value="The reference search parameter 'patient' refers to multiple possible resource types. Please specify a type in the search expression: patient:Patient or patient:Group" /></issue></OperationOutcome>

EXPEkesheth commented 2 months ago

@Thopap - thankyou for reporting the issue. This is a known limitation today and we will add it to our backlog to investigate further.

Thopap commented 2 months ago

@EXPEkesheth - thank you for your response. Do you have any further details here? Is this limitation independed from the data provider? I assume the workaround is to add the ResourceType if there is only 1 resource type that is referenced and to split the query into multiple if more than 1 Resource is possible?

While testing the FHIR Server, i experience, that the ":identifier" modifier seems to be also not supported? E.g. when searching " GET [base]/Observation?subject:identifier=http://acme.org/fhir/identifier/mrn|123456" like mentioned in the fhir spec, i get a error "Modifier 'Identifier' is not supported for search parameter 'subject'."

Is there a list of known limitations in MS Fhir server documented?

EXPEkesheth commented 2 weeks ago

@Thopap - This page provides details on supported modifiers and search result parameters.

Azure FHIR server does not support :identifier modifier today.

Please let me know if you have any additional questions

EXPEkesheth commented 1 week ago

Item for tracking the issue reported: #AB120154