search

microsoft / fluentui-system-icons

Fluent System Icons are a collection of familiar, friendly and modern icons from Microsoft.
https://aka.ms/fluentui-system-icons
MIT License
5.93k stars 517 forks source link

Why are Fabric icons different to Fluent System icons? #470

Open Poopooracoocoo opened 2 years ago

Poopooracoocoo commented 2 years ago

I wasn't sure where to put this but had to ask. Why are Fabric icons or Fluent UI icons and Fluent System icons so different to each other? Wouldn't it be normal to just have one set of icons across Microsoft products? Usage has been unclear: https://github.com/microsoft/fluentui/issues/12488. Google allows anyone to use Material Symbols.

What icons should a Fluent Design app use?

honestly there's so much going on in the fluent ui umbrella but i'm not here for that

spencer-nelson commented 2 years ago

This is mostly a documentation question related to FluentUI, not a Fluent System Icons issue. I'll try to connect the right people to further the discussion regarding usage of icons in FluentUI and how we message intent for Fluent as a system.

That being said, the intent for applications designed using the Fluent Design System is to use Fluent System Icons where possible. On the topic of an icon font, as discussed in the linked issue, it's something that mostly takes resources to support, which we've not really been given. Along those lines, most cases of iconography use are moving toward individual SVG files for display, as it's significantly simpler to handle in many ways, so that's what has been prioritized. If you have a particular need for fonts that isn't already supported, feel welcome to express your need so we can better track and prioritize, and especially feel welcome to fix or work with us to add said support.

Poopooracoocoo commented 2 years ago

I appreciate that response. Looking forward to what those people have to say

Poopooracoocoo commented 2 years ago

@spencer-nelson Could you follow up on your coworkers here?

spencer-nelson commented 2 years ago

Just to update, we are working on progress to help address this and provide further clarity. With Summer holidays a couple of key folks are/have been out on vacation but hope to give better resolution in ~ 2 weeks.

YBAZAN commented 1 year ago

Any news on this point?

Poopooracoocoo commented 1 year ago

@spencer-nelson Any updates on this?

mdtauk commented 1 year ago

@spencer-nelson Any updates on this?

Isn't Fabric now Fluent 2, and isn't it now using the Fluent System Icons?

image

Poopooracoocoo commented 1 year ago

@spencer-nelson Any updates on this?

Isn't Fabric now Fluent 2, and isn't it now using the Fluent System Icons?

Yeah I know but I still think I'd rather see whether Spencer can say Microsoft has truly achieved consistency across platforms with their icons and emoji, so I'll wait for them to close this issue. Especially because https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/fluentui#/styles/web/icons is still up

voidnothings commented 7 months ago

I am also curious on the official take on this.