[BUG]: Android events do not match native events

[Nantris]

System info

• Playwright Version: 1.47.2 v1.39.0 (also appears to affect 1.41 but haven't explicitly run my repro to be sure the issue is identical)
• Operating System: Kubuntu 23.10
• Browser: Android
• Other info:

Source code

https://github.com/Nantris/PlaywrightBeforeInputTest

Steps

See README

Expected

Playwright's events match the native Android events in not sending event.keycode.

The should also match the native behavior of event.preventDefault() - for example deleteContentBackward is not actually preventable in Android Chrome (even though the spec says it should be) - but when run in Playwright the action can be prevented.

Actual

These behaviors don't match the native implementations and so tests can't be trusted to reflect real world results.

Keycode:

At minimum Enter/Space/Backspace are affected by this issue.

I've discovered that Playwright keydown and keyup send an event.code === 'Backspace' on Android, but the softkeys keyboard does not send that code.

Additionally, for Space - it sends a keycode of 32 and a code of Space - but the softkeys produce a keycode of 229 and no code

I strongly suspect these discrepancies are what's breaking many of our tests, because listeners meant for desktop are firing in our mobile app in a way they never would on a real device.

preventDefault: I've also found that event.preventDefault can prevent events which are not actually preventable in real world usage on Android. My hope is that this might be caused by the keycode issue. I do not currently have a repro for this component.

---

Originally discussed in #26796.

[Nantris]

Friendly bump. This issue has a repro repo linked.

[Nantris]

Friendly bump. I understand the holidays slow things down for everyone.

I put together a repro and I've been trying to get attention on this issue for almost two months now and would really appreciate any sort of reply.

[Nantris]

Friendly bump.

[Nantris]

@yury-s I'm sorry to ping you directly. Is there a reason this issue hasn't received any reply?

I understand open source ebbs and flows, but it seems like every other issue receives replies from the maintainers quite quickly, and this one has no replies after over a month despite having a repro linked. I've been struggling with this since August 2023 and first isolated the issue nearly two months ago but I received no reply on the original issue either.

[Nantris]

Bumping.

[Nantris]

Bump.

[Nantris]

[Nantris]

Is there anything I can do to help get this resolved?

As far as I can tell I've checked all the boxes and would really appreciate any update from the devs, even if it's just to say there's no interest in fixing this right now.

[Nantris]

Bump.

[Nantris]

Bump.

[Nantris]

@yury-s @aslushnikov

[Nantris]

Still present in 1.47.2.

[Nantris]

Every single week for years now this makes my life a pain :(

It would be nice if someone could reply even to tell me the Playwright team doesn't care about Android (which I guess they don't.)