Give extension authors access to the Github Codespaces beta - Githubissues

microsoft / vscode

Visual Studio Code

https://code.visualstudio.com

MIT License

162.15k stars 28.53k forks source link

Give extension authors access to the Github Codespaces beta #104199

Closed davidanthoff closed 3 years ago

davidanthoff commented 4 years ago

We (the Julia extension) are now getting reports from users that use our extension with the Github Codespaces beta because they apparently are in. None of us, the core devs of the extension, are part of the beta, and it is tricky to help them with anything.

Could authors of popular extensions jump the queue and get added to the beta so that we can make sure everything works with our extension? In my case, it would just be the Github account here.

IllusionMH commented 4 years ago

I wonder if https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/wiki/How-to-Contribute#run can help here

Web (Chromium, Firefox or Safari only)
yarn web

davidanthoff commented 4 years ago

That is not related at all, I'd like to be part of the GitHub Codespaces beta, like some of our users already are.

davidanthoff commented 4 years ago

Bump, any progress on this? This is really quite an unfortunate situation, where we have users that have access to Codespaces using our extension, and we as the authors can't help them with anything because we are not part of the beta. Isn't there some way that you could just fairly quickly add my account to the beta, i.e. jump the queue?

fiveisprime commented 4 years ago

Sorry for the lack of movement, I'll pick this up this week and may be reaching out for more info to get you in.

fiveisprime commented 4 years ago

I reached out to the Codespaces team and they said your best bet is just to sign up here: https://github.com/features/codespaces The demand to get in is high and they're letting people in as quickly as they can. I'll keep pushing, but it's not looking good.

In the meantime, the image that backs Codespaces is available here (warning, it's kind of gigantic) if you want to try to repro the issues without access. You might want to try to repro with a smaller, more basic container image first.

RandomFractals commented 4 years ago

yeah, that's unfortunate since many devs given access to github codespaces beta try most popular extensions when they get in & how would extension devs provide support for that without being added to that program first.

perhaps, github & codespaces teams need to recalibrate that beta access approach.

davidanthoff commented 4 years ago

I added myself to the beta request queue months ago, I think essentially on the first day it was possible, but haven't been able to get in yet...

I do think there should be some priority for folks that contribute popular extensions.

RandomFractals commented 4 years ago

I agree. I applied for it back in May I believe when it was first announced.

There certainly should be some higher priority set for those contributing to vscode ecosystem & popular twitter devs & youtubers just trying & sharing that github/codespaces integration, as I've seen those channels full of cheers how great code spaces is.

Maybe resetting that priority would make it even better ;)

RandomFractals commented 4 years ago

here is an idea: I think github and code spaces integration teams should connect with vs marketplace team, get 1K of top downloaded extensions with publisher info, which is mostly our github handles & upload that list into their next github/codespaces beta access granted queue to send out.

should not be this hard.

davidanthoff commented 4 years ago

Ok, I just got in :) I guess because of the VS and GitHub Codespaces merge, which seems like great news also!

RandomFractals commented 4 years ago

@davidanthoff are you referring to this announcement?

https://devblogs.microsoft.com/visualstudio/visual-studio-codespaces-is-consolidating-into-github-codespaces/

That is great news! Altho, it did nothing for me. still in the queue :(

@fiveisprime why can't you guys do the same bulk import for the vscode extension publishers registered on vs marketplace?

RandomFractals commented 4 years ago

@fiveisprime also, not sure if this is the best place for it, but would be nice if vscode team provided a short tutorial & best practices guide on enabling vscode extensions for code spaces.

per my reads we need to mark our extensions as UI type in package.json & use new vscode.workspace.fs api for file access, but I am sure there is more to it.

@mattbierner & @eamodio are there any docs or vscode ext. examples you'd recommend for that vscode ext. update dev effort?

davidanthoff commented 4 years ago

Yes, I had a VS Online account for a while, and I believe everyone who had one of those accounts automatically got a GitHub Codespace account now?

RandomFractals commented 4 years ago

@davidanthoff that's great! some of us did not :(

also, @alefragnani kindly pointed me to this doc on marking extesions as workspace, not UI, as I originally mentioned from my memory of reading those updates ...

https://code.visualstudio.com/api/advanced-topics/remote-extensions#incorrect-execution-location

RandomFractals commented 4 years ago

more info on vscode.workspace.fs released back in vscode v1.37 to make fs work for extensions that support remote workspaces, which includes code spaces too:

https://code.visualstudio.com/updates/v1_37?ref=codebldr#_vscodeworkspacefs

RandomFractals commented 4 years ago

all about that new github codespaces integration in one place for ext. devs to peruse :) Thanks @lynnlangit for compiling these!

https://github.com/lynnlangit/learning-codespaces

fiveisprime commented 3 years ago

I'm going to go ahead and close this. If any publishers still need access, let me know either here or through email and I'll make sure you get in.