mihonapp / mihon

Free and open source manga reader for Android
Apache License 2.0
10.05k stars 457 forks source link

Used it for a while, gave some advice #788

Closed 4nfo closed 5 months ago

4nfo commented 5 months ago

Describe your suggested feature

1.I think the bookshelf and the update module can be integrated, so that I think it can be more concise and mihon interface, and when updating, it is no longer cumbersome to click on the update bar and then see the updated manga chapters. 03f1c5a3b5acc28f6d547b45faa6c728

2.A place where it feels like there could be a better experience f1426e6d12b73f04a194a1a793bc9998

3.There should be more options 49e31ab547d8ed09bbadeffe9782b13c

These are the update suggestions that I have brought after using it for a while, and I may just represent my own thoughts, and I personally feel that if they are adopted, the experience of using mihon will be better.

Other details

No response

Acknowledgements

Norsze commented 5 months ago

I don't feel like the first one is adequate enough to replace the updates tab for people who use the updates tab. For people with a lot of entries in a category, or update multiple categories, it will be less easy to overview in a long list with not updated entries in alphabetical order.

I feel like making the Resume button dynamic is just inviting future issues, like what happens when they name their chapter something weird?

Do you have suggestions for these extra options besides Pinned and All? Like specific and not just we need more?

4nfo commented 5 months ago

something In the second question, if only Arabic numerals of chapters are displayed, there should be no strange names.

There is another problem. I don't know whether it is the source or the problem that can be improved from the reader. That is, some comic websites load singular picture tags, for example, 13579, and when the reader reads it, it will repeatedly display two groups of pictures of 1 and then display pictures of 2, which will have a repetition. Can I choose to skip a chapter with duplicate pictures from the reader (I know that the loading tag name of the picture must be regular before it can be realized)Screenshot_2024-05-13-15-31-47-212_app.mihon.jpg

That should be all my feedback.

Norsze commented 5 months ago

In the second question, if only Arabic numerals of chapters are displayed, there should be no strange names.

What about decimals? Many sites name chapters 14.5 or 14.50 or 14.55. some official sources don't even number them and just calls them ex. What about oneshots that don't have any numbers? What about manga very high in chapter numbers, will it visually break on smaller screens? I really feel this is welcoming future issues for no reason when Resume works and has no risk of breaking visually.

AntsyLich commented 5 months ago
  1. No
  2. No
  3. Can be considered. Make separate feature request.
4nfo commented 5 months ago

Ok, but thank you for checking my opinion. I'll come back for feedback if I have any new questions in the future.