search

minetest-mods / stamina

Adds hunger (stamina) to minetest.
17 stars 18 forks source link

position of stamina bar #1

Closed MoNTE48 closed 8 years ago

MoNTE48 commented 8 years ago

This is a great idea and make it easier to rewrite a very hard hud and hunger. But I see some issues. I believe that we should stick to the location of the bars Minecraft: armor air health hunger Let me explain why. When we see this: hunger health we occupied all the space on the left, but a lot of free space on the right. We really rarely swim under water. Just display Armor hunger armor healt In my opinion it is not aesthetically pleasing, and stupid. Armour is directly related to health, they need to be one below the other. Do not diagonally.

sofar commented 8 years ago

Noted.

sofar commented 8 years ago

I'm going to close this feature request. But I'd like to explain why I"m not currently considering this in detail.

I didn't set out to replace the hunger+hud mods when I assembled this code. I also do not intend to maintain a hostile fork of these 2 mods, so, for the purposes of this mod, if people request changes that make it work more like the original mods, then I'd like to ask that they please consider using those two mods together instead.

Second, for the technical argument, I do not want to start juggling the internal statbars. This is out of scope of what I want to achieve with this code. To explain more in-depth: the builtin breath statbar would need to be moved in order to do what you want. The code needed to do this would force me to re-implement large parts of what hud does. I want to keep the code small, and focus on the gameplay effects, not on the cosmetics.

You have the option of forking this mod, attempting to convince me with patches[1], or work with @blockment on improving his version to suit your needs. But this issue is closed unless [1].

MoNTE48 commented 8 years ago

Good. This mode can be used in conjunction with HUD (instead of hunger)?