search

minetest / contentdb

A content database for Minetest mods, games, and more
https://content.minetest.net
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
98 stars 47 forks source link

The "Drugs" tag is poorly defined #540

Open Wuzzy2 opened 5 months ago

Wuzzy2 commented 5 months ago

The "Drugs" tag definition reads as follows:

Contains illegal drugs, such as marijuana

This is wrong. Marijuana isn't illegal everywhere. So this tag is biased towards countries that make it illegal.

I think the definition of the "Drugs" tag needs to be better, more well-defined and most-importantly, neutral.

We have a similar tag called "Alcohol / Tobacco". This is well-defined and doesn't need any change.

Solution

I suggest the following changes:

Yes, the new tag name is longer but the term "Drugs" alone is too vague and may be misleading. Alcohol and tobacco are drugs, too, so this is irreducible complexity. This tag is used as a content warning, so I think clarity is more important than brevity.

Alternative solution

Another option would be to redesign all drugs-related tags from the ground-up but this means all packages have to be carefully re-reviewed and re-tagged and I don't know if this is worth the effort.

rubenwardy commented 5 months ago

ContentDB's content warnings are largely based on PEGI warnings. The Alcohol/Tabacco and Drugs content warnings are inspired by the Drugs PEGI warning, although I split them into two as I felt that it would be beneficial to users.

image

I've changed the description to "Contains recreational drugs other than alcohol or tobacco". Medical drugs like health packs or whatever don't need a content warning

Wuzzy2 commented 5 months ago

Well, in that case, PEGI sucks. :-) As I said, the term "illegal drugs" is a weasel word because there are about 190 countries worldwide with different laws and regulations.

I like your new definition, it is good. What do you think about my new proposed tag name itself?

Dragonop commented 4 months ago

I disagree on renaming the tag itself, since by being overly specific the CDB staff lose versatility when applying content warnings

My feel is that the new description is sufficiently graphic in making sure people understand it referes to the "harder" drugs, and not stuff like tobacco, alcohol, or even coffee or medicine

That said, and most importantly, renaming to "Drugs (not alcohol/tobacco)" is both redundant with the "Alcohol / Tobacco" tag and with the new description.