search

minio / sidekick

High Performance HTTP Sidecar Load Balancer
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
540 stars 82 forks source link

Configuring multiple pools cannot support read requests #80

Closed Hintic closed 1 year ago

Hintic commented 1 year ago

The sidekick running on the current server is as follows: sidekick --health-path=/minio/health/ready http://site1-minio{1...4}:9000,http://site1-minio{5...8}:9000

Current Behavior

  1. I create buckets with the same name in two sets of clusters, and then configure them into a list of pools in sidekick。
  2. When sending an upload request through this sidekick, I found that the stored files will be roughly divided into two pools, but when I call the statObject or download request, I find that sometimes I can get 200 successfully, and sometimes I can’t get 404.

Possible Solution

Does this mean that sidekick only supports request sharing among multiple pools, regardless of whether it is read or write?

My Environment

cache: enabled version: sidekick:2.0.8

harshavardhana commented 1 year ago

sidekick is not meant to combine two different clusters, you need first a cluster of MinIO with two pools.

Those pools are specified to sidekick via comma separated list.

Hintic commented 1 year ago

In addition, I would like to ask a small question. Can a cluster of MinIO with two pools be created in K8S without an Operator? Is there any relevant information?

harshavardhana commented 1 year ago

In addition, I would like to ask a small question. Can a cluster of MinIO with two pools be created in K8S without an Operator? Is there any relevant information?

We only recommend the operator, of course, you can do it without an operator as well - but that is not what we document or recommend, or test. You are on your own if you want to not use the Operator. @Hintic