dvpackager GUI - MOV seems to be default output even when it's not selected

mipops / dvrescue

Archivist-made software that supports data migration from DV tapes into digital files suitable for long-term preservation. Snapshot daily builds are at https://mediaarea.net/download/snapshots/binary/dvrescue/.

BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License

91 stars 20 forks source link

dvpackager GUI - MOV seems to be default output even when it's not selected #684

Open libbyhopfauf opened 1 year ago

libbyhopfauf commented 1 year ago

In the dvpackager GUI, if I have two or more files (file-1, file-2, file-3, etc.) loaded into packager and I have already added files to the queue for file-1, once I select file-2 and my segmenting rules and click add to queue, the wrapper applied is .mov even though .mkv was still selected. This happens every time, even if I don't make any changes to any of the segmenting rules, file location or wrapper. I noticed that if I change the selection to .mov, then back to .mkv and then click "add to queue" that the files added will add as .mkv files. But I have to do this every time for every files I have before adding each set of segments to the queue. See video example below:

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/13877631/227683203-4a14c70c-55d4-4074-80dc-139944168ef0.mov

ElderOrb commented 10 months ago

@libbyhopfauf is it still an issue ?

ElderOrb commented 9 months ago

@libbyhopfauf ^^

libbyhopfauf commented 7 months ago

@ElderOrb sorry, I just saw this! Yes, so far, I have to toggle back to .mov and then back to .mkv before clicking "add to queue" otherwise dvpackager packages the file as a .mov. Here is a screen recording I took today using the latest release:

https://github.com/mipops/dvrescue/assets/13877631/4c9c2cda-c428-4485-9a61-a53ac3bc8724

ElderOrb commented 7 months ago

@libbyhopfauf hmmm, for some reasons video doesn't play correctly - can only see a few first frames. But based on 'toggle back to .mov and then back to .mkv' looks like you are not on the latest version - cause in the latest version 'mov' is a default selection in UI

ElderOrb commented 7 months ago

@dericed is it reproducible for you too?

libbyhopfauf commented 7 months ago

@libbyhopfauf hmmm, for some reasons video doesn't play correctly - can only see a few first frames. But based on 'toggle back to .mov and then back to .mkv' looks like you are not on the latest version - cause in the latest version 'mov' is a default selection in UI

@ElderOrb I'm sorry that was confusing. Below is a video I took today using version 2024-02-10. But in case that one doesn't work on your end either, here are the steps I took:

imported file
selected segmentation rules
clicked apply
selected MKV
clicked "add to queue"
video exports as MKV
imported a second file
selected segmentation rules
clicked "apply"
since MKV was already selected, I clicked "add to queue"
file shows up in queue and exports as MOV
if I make no changes, but select MOV and then reselect MKV and add the file to the queue it exports as MKV.

https://github.com/mipops/dvrescue/assets/13877631/42ccf316-31e3-47ee-9e0f-969a8679c011

dericed commented 2 months ago

@libbyhopfauf I can't reproduce this with the latest daily build. Can you confirm?

dericed commented 1 month ago

ping to @libbyhopfauf