search

mirage / qubes-mirage-firewall

A Mirage firewall VM for QubesOS
BSD 2-Clause "Simplified" License
211 stars 28 forks source link

Mirage firewall doesn't go well with NAT #114

Closed ContemplatingSuicide closed 2 years ago

ContemplatingSuicide commented 4 years ago

So I installed the latest mirage firewall sha256sum 686287eb5737fd0cad91b36824704ee...., I then connected whonix-gw to it. Now I'm using snowflake (https://snowflake.torproject.org) there as a pluggable transport, but unfortunately it seems like it doesn't work with most tries (note that it's working perfectly fine now that I switched back to the normal sys-firewall).

(How to replicate: 1. Install fresh mirage firewall. 2. Connect a fresh debian VM to it. 3. Download the latest Tor Browser alpha. 4. Choose 'snowflake' as a pluggable transport when connecting. 5. With most tries it won't connect.)

I suspect this may have to do with NAT.

xaki23 commented 4 years ago

what "NAT" are you talking about there?

tor is "good luck with that"-ware half the time. sys-whonix below a mirage-firewall works here. i am pretty sure i would notice most kinds of "nat problem".

hannesm commented 2 years ago

No activity in > 1 year (missing information from original reporter). I'll close this, please reopen with the information requested by @xaki23.