search

mkeeter / antimony

CAD from a parallel universe
2.1k stars 159 forks source link

.stl file size. #10

Open andershaldin opened 9 years ago

andershaldin commented 9 years ago

I get really huge file size when exporting to .stl, even for simple meshes. So obviously there is a balance between file size and quality of the mesh. But in this simple example I get the following file sizes

8 voxel = 3MB 16 voxel = 12.7MB 32 voxel = 51.7MB 64 voxel = 207.4MB

voxel_export It seems a bit over the top to me, but not sure if there is anything we can do about it?

mkeeter commented 9 years ago

Yes -- .stl export is a naive marching tetrahedrons algorithm at the moment (which quickly blows up in size).

Pull requests to improve it are welcome; for now, I'd bring the meshes into meshlab and decimate them there.

andershaldin commented 9 years ago

Thanks for the reply, would love to help but my programming skill level is far to low :( I really like working in antimony but file size and export time is very unfortunate.

Keep up the good work! :)

mkeeter commented 9 years ago

The experimental feature detection in more recent builds lets you preserve sharp corners and edges while using a much lower voxel resolution. It's not full-on decimation, but could help with filesize woes.

unlimitedbacon commented 9 years ago

I think the thing that would help the most would be to merge groups of adjacent coplanar faces. Right now flat surfaces are composed of lots of small polygons, which are redundant.