mml-book / mml-book.github.io

Companion webpage to the book "Mathematics For Machine Learning"
12.91k stars 2.39k forks source link

Clarification regarding Equation 10.37a #712

Open SachinVashisth opened 2 years ago

SachinVashisth commented 2 years ago

fig1

The equation 10.37a shown above uses the coordinates zdn for the original data point xn. The limits used for the summation are from d = 1 to D. Also, It is concluded in one of the points (on Page no 328 - 329) that coordinates of original data point x and projected data point are identical for limits only from m = 1 to M as shown below

fig3 where equations 10.26 and 10.27 are shown below fig4

So, why are we using the coordinates zdn for the original data point xn in 10.37a for the limit from d = 1 to D? isn't it should be only from d = 1 to M?

Location

  1. version 29-7-2021
  2. Chapter 10
  3. page 330
  4. equation number 10.37a

Proposed solution The equation 10.37a can be modified as fig5 Here, from the limit d = 1 to M, we have used the coordinates identical to the ones used in projected points while from p = M+1 to D, some suitable coordinates ζ pn are used.

Please clarify.