mml-book / mml-book.github.io

Companion webpage to the book "Mathematics For Machine Learning"
13.11k stars 2.42k forks source link

2.18 should just be a linear transformation, not an automorphism #755

Open jwmdykes opened 1 year ago

jwmdykes commented 1 year ago

Describe the mistake For exercise 2.18, the linear maps f and g should just be linear transformations, not automorphisms. If f and g are automorphisms they're bijective, so their kernels are {0} and the question becomes trivial. For example in ker(f) = ker(g dot f) everything just cancels to the set {0} and there's no need to use the condition that g dot f = id_E.

Location

  1. version Draft (2023-02-15) of “Mathematics for Machine Learning”.
  2. Chapter chapter 2 exercises
  3. page Page 68 in the ebook

Proposed solution Change "Let f and g be two automorphisms on E" to "Let f and g be two endomorphisms on E."