search

modelica / fmi-guides

Repo for "FMI Best Practice Guide for Implementers" (and maybe more guides)
https://modelica.github.io/fmi-guides/main/fmi-guide/
Other
18 stars 11 forks source link

Changes to "Basic HiL & Sensor HiL Profile" #44

Open chrbertsch opened 2 years ago

chrbertsch commented 2 years ago

Regarding: https://modelica.github.io/fmi-guides/main/fmi-profiles/#_basic_hil_sensor_hil_profile

I propose to move "Scheduled Execution Interface" from required to optional.

"New Integer Types" have to be supported anyway, we can remove this.

"Source Code FMUs" and "Binary FMUs for non-Desktop Platforms (e.g. HiL)" should be alternatives, not both have to be supported

pmai commented 2 years ago

Proposal from design meeting 2022-07-26:

Aside: The naming of profiles and explanations should be regularized and enhanced (e.g. point out that the sensors in this profile are perception sensors, etc.).

DagBruck commented 1 year ago

We see many "classical" HIL applications that do not have perception sensors, e.g. drivelines and servos. If we call those Basic HIL, there is little need for Binary Data Types.

MBlesken commented 1 year ago

Regarding: https://modelica.github.io/fmi-guides/main/fmi-profiles/#_basic_hil_sensor_hil_profile

I propose to move "Scheduled Execution Interface" from required to optional.

Agreed. Let's do it.

"New Integer Types" have to be supported anyway, we can remove this.

Agreed. Let's remove it. Also in other profiles.

"Source Code FMUs" and "Binary FMUs for non-Desktop Platforms (e.g. HiL)" should be alternatives, not both have to be supported

Same goes for Desktop: Actually "Binary FMUs for Desktop Platforms" makes no sense in this profile. Let's remove it.

Also remove "Binary Data Type Parameters", or at least make it recommended.

MBlesken commented 1 year ago

Why is there a separate "Sensor Profile"? It could be confusing. For example "OSI-encoded sensor data via binary variables" is an important use case on HIL simulators, too. (Of course "Variable Co-Simulation Communication Step Size" and "Binary FMUs for Desktop Platforms" should not be mandatory)