search

modelsbuilder / ModelsBuilder.Original

The Community Models Builder for Umbraco
MIT License
113 stars 49 forks source link

VS2022 #258

Open qz2rg4 opened 2 years ago

qz2rg4 commented 2 years ago

Good Day,

Do you perhaps have an idea when Models Builder Extention for VS2022 will be made available ?

zpqrtbnk commented 2 years ago

Hey,

We do not have a team of active maintainers for Models Builder at the moment and therefore work on porting the extension to VS2022 has not started. VS2022 requires a separate build for the extensions, because of some changes in extensions management. As such, we cannot tell if nor when the VS2022 extension will be available.

I have done the job for my own SolutionBook personal extension a while ago and it may be used as inspiration. It is not horribly complex, just annoying. But, we need someone with a bit of time to volunteer.

Anyone?

zpqrtbnk commented 2 years ago

By popular demand ;)

The issue with Visual Studio 2022 is that the Extensions mechanisms have changed enough that a single VSIX cannot support both Visual Studio 2019 and Visual Studio 2022. Therefore, a different VSIX has to be produced for Visual Studio 2022. For instance, for my SolutionBook extension, I produce SolutionBook.2019.vsix and SolutionBook.2022.vsix.

Microsoft provides a comprehensive documentation about the upgrade process. I have done this for SolutionBook in July 2021 and it spans over less than a dozen commits, and it should not be too hard to follow.

For anyone wanting to give it a try, here is how I would do it. I would add two projects to the solution: Our.ModelsBuilder.Extension.2019 and Our.ModelsBuilder.Extension.2022. I would move everything VSIX-related from Our.ModelsBuilder.Extension into Our.ModelsBuilder.Extension.2019, only leaving in Our.ModelsBuilder.Extension the bits that are Visual Studio version-agnostic. Then verify that the solution can still generate the correct VSIX for Visual Studio 2019. Then, populate the .2022 project so that it can generate the new VSIX for Visual Studio 2022.

The trick is in getting things right, putting the right dependencies in each project, etc. And this is where copying from SolutionBook may be a quick way to do it. Hint: I did SolutionBook by copying from others.

I unfortunately don't have the bandwidth to deal with this now (or with the other issues that have accumulated...) but this is an administrative task that does not require any real nor deep knowledge of ModelsBuilder, C#, anything really. It's just moving files around. Don't be scared.

Anyone?

jamiehowarth0 commented 2 years ago

@zpqrtbnk I'm having a crack at this now. Hoping it's not too difficult.

benehudson commented 2 years ago

@jamiehowarth0 @zpqrtbnk following. I badly need a vsix for 2022. I also see modelsbuilder isn't ready for Umbraco V9. Is there anyone on Umbraco staff that could pickup Stephan's work? Modelsbuilder is crucial!!! I was ready to start a new V9 project in 2 weeks, but without modelsbuilder I'm going to pump the brakes on that.

motohead400 commented 1 year ago

Any chance anyone has taken this on? @jamiehowarth0 were you able to get this to work?