module-federation / module-federation-examples

Implementation examples of module federation , by the creators of module federation
https://module-federation.io/
MIT License
5.66k stars 1.75k forks source link

A few issues with Modern.js ssr #4298

Open yay opened 4 weeks ago

yay commented 4 weeks ago
  1. Running the Modern.js SSR example in dev mode works great. But building the host app fails with Cannot find module 'remote/Image' or its corresponding type declarations., which can be fixed by casting the module name to any:

    const RemoteSSRComponent = createRemoteSSRComponent({
        // `npm run build` error: Cannot find module 'remote/Image' or its corresponding type declarations.
        loader: () => import("remote/Image" as any),

    Is there a better way to fix it?

  2. How does one get type hinting to work? If I add a prop to the Image component in the provider and try using it in the host app on the imported <RemoteSSRComponent />, I get a type error.

  3. Even though TypeScript doesn't recognize the prop, it does work and is passed to the remote Image component. However, every time I change the prop from the host -- e.g. a counter increment -- I see the page flash for a split second with "Loading..." shown in place of both components before they show up again. How do I prevent this from happening?

    const Index = () => {
        const [counter, setCounter] = React.useState(0);
        return (
            <div className="container-box">
                <button onClick={() => setCounter(counter + 1)}>+1</button>
                <RemoteSSRComponent counter={counter} />
                <DynamicRemoteSSRComponents />
            </div>
        );
    };

    https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/9b06a193-12d1-457c-a794-06bb08b8b506

  4. Running all three apps in dev mode works just fine, but when previewing the production build locally with npm run serve the host fails with a CORS error:

    Screenshot 2024-10-27 at 10 02 37 PM

    Do you know how to fix this one? I struggled to find anything online and in Modern.js docs.

  5. When serving, navigating to http://localhost:3007/mf-manifest.json and http://localhost:3008/mf-manifest.json shows a blank page with only 404 text in it. Is this normal? It doesn't happen when running in dev mode.

  6. When running in dev mode, I sometimes see the following host app console errors: Screenshot 2024-10-27 at 10 30 15 PM

    Screenshot 2024-10-27 at 10 35 46 PM

    I haven't been able to consistently reproduce it. Do you know what might be causing them?

2heal1 commented 3 weeks ago

hey , for the question 1 , i can not reproduce the error in my local while executing pnpm build in host , have you executed pnpm install in root dir ?

2heal1 commented 3 weeks ago

For the question 2 , it also works on my PC , but i'm not sure whether the monorepo has wrong configuration , so i split the examples , you can try this repo

https://github.com/2heal1/basic-modernjs-ssr-demo

The remote component should have type image

2heal1 commented 3 weeks ago

For the question 3 , it's a bug , i will fix it https://github.com/module-federation/core/pull/3139

2heal1 commented 3 weeks ago

For the question 4 , this need you add cors header in browser currently . And i will add one debug plugin for this case

2heal1 commented 3 weeks ago

For the question 5 , because i add devServer.headers in modernjs plugin , so it can work normally in dev mode . But this configuration can not work for modernjs serve , so it can not be accessible. This question is quite the same as question 4 , I think i can solve it by providing a modern-js-mf-debug-plugin.

For workaround, you can use serve package by executing serve dist -C -p [port] to serve provider and dynamic-provider , and pnpm serve to serve host

2heal1 commented 3 weeks ago

For question 6, it should be fixed in a preview version , i will release it next week

2heal1 commented 3 weeks ago

Because in byte , we don't use serve command usually , so i don't consider this case when i develop this feature , very glad you can help point out those issues :D