mollyim / mollyim-android

Enhanced and security-focused fork of Signal.
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
1.37k stars 77 forks source link

Replace internal photo Gallery with "open system gallery" #302

Open firefoxlover opened 3 months ago

firefoxlover commented 3 months ago

Is there an existing request for this?

Feature description

EDIT

I do not longer request to use that photo picker portal. it totally sucks and doesnt show random images. Please instead embed the "select image from system gallery" where the default gallery like Fossify Gallery can be used.

The photo picker portal allows to remove the need for any persistent storage access, highly improving security. Signal is completely broken as it doesnt use it, and you need to select photos as files or use the share dialog to bypass this.

gif of the portal

Signal doesnt seem to care about implementing this.

I am not an Android dev but it shouldnt be hard to implement the portal and remove the internal gallery instead.

greensheeps commented 2 months ago

I remember seeing that the the Play Store will be forcing none gallery apps to use the photo picker instead so Signal will be forced to do this anyway

firefoxlover commented 2 months ago

yay? But hopefully the "open systems used gallery" is possible, as after using it a bit, the android image picker portal totally sucks (it shows only a random subset of the available images)