monarch-initiative / phenopacket-store

Collections of GA4GH phenopackets that represent individuals with Mendelian diseases.
https://monarch-initiative.github.io/phenopacket-store/
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
14 stars 4 forks source link

LMNA #63

Closed pnrobinson closed 7 months ago

pnrobinson commented 7 months ago

Remove Barthelemy (atypical course which muddies the waters) @ielis -- make copy if need be.

pnrobinson commented 7 months ago

Remove Novelli since it is one patient. with incomplete clinical description @ielis

pnrobinson commented 7 months ago

Remove Patni (it is a novel syndrome not yet listed in OMIM) @ielis

pnrobinson commented 7 months ago

Remove Simha (it is a mixed phenotype that does not match exactly with existing OMIM identifiers). There are quite a few of these kinds of case reports but it is hard now to know what to do with them and the clinical descriptions are heterogeneous and perhaps best left for a separate study. @ielis

pnrobinson commented 7 months ago

@ielis remove Van Esch -- a novel syndrome of arthropathy, tendinous calcinosis, and progeroid features. (see above comment)

Remove Zirn -- same comment

pnrobinson commented 7 months ago

@ielis I would also tend to remove Wiltshire, since only one individual is described in detail, which necessarily adds to apparent hetergeneity (no way to know)

pnrobinson commented 7 months ago

We have the following diseases

We have over 10 individuals for each disease except the last (I have reached out to two authors of large cohorts for the last). I would suggest we delete the rest, since it is hard to judge the effects with small groups of other diseases (e.g., Emery-Dreifuss recessive). Please save the files in data elsewhere, and we should remove them for now from here!

ielis commented 7 months ago

Hi, thanks a lot for the phenopackets! I'll add these into the pipeline.

pnrobinson commented 7 months ago

I still need to fix a few minor errors and export the final LMNA phenopackets. If you are ok, I will delete the files and will be adding more cohorts of LMNA this week.

ielis commented 7 months ago

Yes, please go forward with deleting the files and adding more LMNA cohorts.

pnrobinson commented 7 months ago

done