mongoose-os-apps / shelly-homekit

Apple HomeKit firmware for Shelly's
Other
1.78k stars 128 forks source link

Support for Shelly Plus 2PM #1013

Closed herzkerl closed 2 months ago

herzkerl commented 2 years ago

I couldn‘t find any comments regarding the Plus 2PM, is there any news regarding this device?

JordiSabria commented 1 year ago

Hello @timoschilling. I've installed 10 Shelly Plus 2PM in my parent's house and I'm wondering how do you have the development of homekit integration. Sorry I don't want to pressure you. I just asking how it goes. I think you are making an incredible job and I going to make an donation in your paypal because what you are doing in this integration is helping me a lot in my home and event in further, because I installed shellys in my parent's house, my sister's house and event in my friend's house. Thanks you very much.

Captain-Chaos13 commented 1 year ago

@timoschilling: i‘m waiting too😉 hope you are successful!

smuel09 commented 1 year ago

Hi @timoschilling Thank you for your hard work. Is there an option to install other Shelly firmware on the plus2PM for the time being or it doesn't work like that?

antoine4livre commented 1 year ago

+1 It would be amazing ! 🙏

sebr5884 commented 1 year ago

Any updates on this? Is a firmware available now?

failbit commented 1 year ago

Would really love this aswell!!

TheBigNeo commented 1 year ago

I already had to replace 2 Shelly 2.5 this month. Yesterday the third died and now the 2.5 are no longer available. :(

Sorbat commented 1 year ago

I already had to replace 2 Shelly 2.5 this month. Yesterday the third died and now the 2.5 are no longer available. :(

I found some on amazon.it last week https://www.amazon.it/dp/B08YNVSBSS/

tillmanz-valooba commented 1 year ago

Hi there! Just checking in on how things are progressing. :-) Apart from my financial contribution is there anything additionally that I could possibly do to support @timoschilling or @rojer with this?

CincoD2 commented 1 year ago

Also waiting this, @rojer ! I'd contribute to get it!

Tillman-Z commented 1 year ago

Hi @timoschilling 😀 It would be great if you could share some info on the current state of the Plus 2PM support. Are you still working on it?

lorenzspenger commented 1 year ago

Just so you know: You can use the Tasmota FW on the Shelly Plus 2 PM with Matter and integrate it natively in Apple Home.

https://tasmota.github.io/docs/Matter/

hughfr4nc15 commented 1 year ago

Just so you know: You can use the Tasmota FW on the Shelly Plus 2 PM with Matter and integrate it natively in Apple Home.

https://tasmota.github.io/docs/Matter/

Isn't Shelly gonna release native firmware with matter support for the Plus devices soon?

jonasman commented 1 year ago

@hughfr4nc15 yes they will. the CTO mentioned on reddit Q2, possibly Q3 2023

However since i dont like to wait, i installed a raspberry PI with Homebridge and my shellies are all on homekit now. Plus you get the native shelly app to count energy

timoschilling commented 1 year ago

Sorry brows no news form my site, I worked on it for multiple weeks in the last months, but I can't resolve the problems. The open problems are:

  1. revert to stock didn't work
  2. power measurement didn't work
  3. revision detection (there at least two hardware revision out there, with different pinouts)
hughfr4nc15 commented 1 year ago

@jonasman I actually have used the plug-in back when the Shelly Duo's were not supported by this firmware. Are the Shelly Plus 2PM supported? Can't find them in the list of supported devices.

jtowe1 commented 1 year ago

@hughfr4nc15 yes they will. the CTO mentioned on reddit Q2, possibly Q3 2023

However since i dont like to wait, i installed a raspberry PI with Homebridge and my shellies are all on homekit now. Plus you get the native shelly app to count energy

Thanks for this! I already had homebridge working but didn't realize there was a plugin. I'm now using it instead of this firmware.

Psycoribble commented 1 year ago

Sorry brows no news form my site, I worked on it for multiple weeks in the last months, but I can't resolve the problems. The open problems are:

  1. revert to stock didn't work
  2. power measurement didn't work
  3. revision detection (there at least two hardware revision out there, with different pinouts)

Hope u can solve these Problems. I want to use my new Shelly 2 PM for my Roller Shutters

jonasman commented 1 year ago

@hughfr4nc15 there are 2 plugins, one for the gen 1 and another for gen 2 here's the gen 2 plugin: https://github.com/alexryd/homebridge-shelly-ng

hughfr4nc15 commented 1 year ago

Yes. Actually noticed that yesterday!Thanks.On 13 Jul 2023, at 16:02, João Nunes @.***> wrote: @hughfr4nc15 there are 2 plugins, one for the gen 1 and another for gen 2 here's the gen 2 plugin: https://github.com/alexryd/homebridge-shelly-ng/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+sort%3Aupdated-desc

—Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

lieberjott commented 1 year ago

Really hope that the problems can be solved, as some of my Shelly 2.5 are dying too :( Did also send some little money in order to support the great effort.

digaus commented 1 year ago
"SNSW-002P16EU" and "SNSW-102P16EU" are the two revisions
Alcor72 commented 1 year ago

Really hope that the problems can be solved, as some of my Shelly 2.5 are dying too :( Did also send some little money in order to support the great effort.

Same here… all my Shelly 2.5 are dying after 2 years of good job. Hope that the new version will be more reliable with the ease of the HomeKit firmware inside… that would be the perfect roller shutter relay!

hughfr4nc15 commented 1 year ago

I already started installing Plus 2PM's and integrating them in Homekit via Homebridge.

DenisKost commented 1 year ago

+1 Would love to know what's the ETA on this!

solitpapa commented 1 year ago

can't wait for your update for shelly 2pm, as solution with Homebridge is not perfect. :( missing points:

all above is working perfect on 2.5 with your firmware.

dennisherzing commented 1 year ago

Hi , is there any news on supporting Plus 2PM? thank you

desek90 commented 1 year ago

Hi, I would also like to know if there is any news on that. I would highly appreciate Plus 2PM support!

dodvip123 commented 1 year ago

did anyone try this already? Flash New Shelly Plus 2PM for Apple HomeKit by OTA: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1VA9xkROiQc&ab_channel=RavenSystem

dennisherzing commented 1 year ago

this looks interesting, lets give it a try ;-) thank you

dodvip123 commented 1 year ago

let us know how it goes! I'm planning to buy the Plus 2PM in the future so cannot test yet

hughfr4nc15 commented 1 year ago

I'm using Homebridge at the moment to make this work, because I was already using it for different accessories so that was simple, but, why not wait for the official firmware with Matter support? Shouldn't take that long to release I believe.

That Tasmota option seems to need a lot of work for it to work and is it easily reversible when the official firmware arrives?

vek030 commented 1 year ago

Please Support this Shelly

hejsiri commented 1 year ago

I am working on a project that will allow the garage door to be opened from a web browser on The Display Tesla cars. Shelly 2.5 works great in HomeKit as a garage door because it has the ability to connect 2 opening sensors. Using two sensors is the only smart solution to make it work just fine. The problem is that Shelly 2.5 is no longer sold. Maybe it would be worthwhile to release a beta version of the mongoose software for Shelly 2PM without the features that are not yet completed? For me, and I'm sure for many people here, it would be valuable if it worked at least as a simple switch and garage door opener. I would be happy and could continue working on my project. For the moment I don't know whether to look for another way or, however, to base the project on Shelly 2PM.

garage-Tesla-Y-opening-3-Current-View

hejsiri commented 11 months ago

Referring to the control of the garage door.... is it possible to connect two opening sensors to Shelly Plus 1 or Shelly Plus 1PM with HomeKit software? Is the Shelly Add-on supported?

timoschilling commented 11 months ago

To answer the beta / preview question: It would be possible, but it maybe results in a device which never can be backflashed to stock. That's a to hard point in my view. Expect because I can't guarantee that the power measuring will be solved in the future.

solitpapa commented 11 months ago

To answer the beta / preview question: It would be possible, but it maybe results in a device which never can be backflashed to stock. That's a to hard point in my view. Expect because I can't guarantee that the power measuring will be solved in the future.

From my perspective and I assume that many others power management is not crucial feature. Backflash to stock will be worth to have, but based on my experience - once flashed to your OS the coming back to stock is not needed, as long as shelly homekit os will follow to updates of homekit. Im really interested in having possibility to update my 2pm to beta version with mentioned cons.

hejsiri commented 11 months ago

It would be great if the Shelly 2PM software would at least have a function to open the garage door with 2 opening sensors, exactly like Shelly 2.5. Many people are waiting for this. Current measurement is a minor function for me. I remind you that Shelly 2.5 is not available for sale.

solitpapa commented 11 months ago

Personally I would love to have control of roller shutter similar as 2.5. As 2.5 are dying one by one in my system, there is no worthy alternative. So having beta version capable to manage the above will be more than welcome. Timo - I keep finger crossed for finding some kind of solution to release beta.

hejsiri commented 11 months ago

From my perspective and I assume that many others power management is not crucial feature. Backflash to stock will be worth to have, but based on my experience - once flashed to your OS the coming back to stock is not needed, as long as shelly homekit os will follow to updates of homekit. Im really interested in having possibility to update my 2pm to beta version with mentioned cons.

I, too, am willing to forgo a return to the original software, provided there is an OTA update option in Shelly-Homekit for 2PM.

MartinMuehlner commented 11 months ago

To answer the beta / preview question: It would be possible, but it maybe results in a device which never can be backflashed to stock. That's a to hard point in my view. Expect because I can't guarantee that the power measuring will be solved in the future.

I would not need Power Measuring - just the same functions as 2,5 and I am good to go;) (using it as roller shutter, but since the "old" ones are dying I already swapped two to the 2pm)

timoschilling commented 11 months ago

Using it a s roller shutter would not work with the current state of the +2PM. Roller shutter requires power measurement.

solitpapa commented 11 months ago

Using it a s roller shutter would not work with the current state of the +2PM. Roller shutter requires power measurement.

Damn, this is unfortunately not good news... is there any chance that the development of 2pm will be continued to try to sort out the power management issue?

thebobx commented 11 months ago

I am in the same situation, my 2.5 are dying and I didn't find a similar module (Wifi + homekit) for my roller shutters. So really hopping for the support of the 2pm here. Thanks.

hughfr4nc15 commented 11 months ago

I am in the same situation, my 2.5 are dying and I didn't find a similar module (Wifi + homekit) for my roller shutters. So really hopping for the support of the 2pm here. Thanks.

I already started installing Plus 2PM's and integrating them in Homekit via Homebridge.

thebobx commented 11 months ago

Do you use "homebridge-shelly-ng" ? Reading github issues it seams that 2PM are not working properly with physical buttons, is it ok for you ?

hughfr4nc15 commented 11 months ago

Do you use "homebridge-shelly-ng" ? Reading github issues it seams that 2PM are not working properly with physical buttons, is it ok for you ?

Yep. Mine are working properlly... via Homekit, physical or Shelly app.

solitpapa commented 11 months ago

Do you use "homebridge-shelly-ng" ? Reading github issues it seams that 2PM are not working properly with physical buttons, is it ok for you ?

Yep. Mine are working properlly... via Homekit, physical or Shelly app.

Dont you have following issues?

These are cons which I discovered, as I also have one 2PM with homebridge

hughfr4nc15 commented 11 months ago

Yes, I have both... Not a big deal though (for me at least). If you ask Siri to set the shade at a xx% it will work (the second point).

knabalex commented 10 months ago

Same problem ... my shellys 2.5 are dying and there is no device which can replace the roller shutter function ... returning to original software (Backflash) is not a necessary feature