search

moodle-an-hochschulen / moodle-local_boostnavigation

Moodle plugin which tries to overcome some fixed appearance behaviours of Boost's nav drawer in a clean way
GNU General Public License v3.0
39 stars 28 forks source link

Collapsible nodes do not collapse under Moodle 3.8 #49

Closed pennedav closed 4 years ago

pennedav commented 4 years ago

During my testing of Moodle 3.8 in preparation for the upcoming release I noticed that collapsible nodes do not collapse. This is with plugin version 2019082700 (release 3.7-r3) under Moodle 3.8dev+ (Build: 20191031) (version 2019103100.00). Given that we're past the Moodle code freeze for 3.8 I doubt this is a bug that will be resolved between now and the official release of 3.8 in a week or so. The problem does not appear on Moodle 3.7.1+ (Build: 20190712) (version 2019052001.01). I've included two screenshots of the Chrome developer tools: one from 3.7 and one from 3.8.

The issue appears to be that under 3.8 the navigation now encloses the <a> tags in an <li> tag so the styles that should be hiding the child items is not getting applied. See screenshots. Note the orange arrows in the 3.8 screenshot and note that proper styling is not being applied as indicated in the style area of the Chrome tools.

Moodle 3.7 screenshot:

Moodle 3 7

Moodle 3.8 screenshot:

Screen Shot 2019-11-01 at 10 33 19 AM

Edit: Updated 3.8 screenshot so it actually shows the proper state when the item should be collapsed but is not. Previous screenshot had data-hidden="0", updated has data-hidden="1" but item is not hidden.

pennedav commented 4 years ago

This is still an issue after upgrading to the official 3.8 release.

abias commented 4 years ago

Hi @pennedav ,

thank you for raising this issue.

This issue seems to be caused by the change of the HTML structure in Boost's navigation drawer in https://tracker.moodle.org/browse/MDL-65406. We will try this within out 3.8 release, but this will take some more days to be finished as our internal release cycle is multiple months behind the Moodle core cycle and some other things still have higher priority at the moment.

If you can provide a pull request with a solution, this would be warmly welcome.

Thanks, Alex

pennedav commented 4 years ago

@abias I've created a pull request for a small change that seems to fix the issue for me. I would expect there are some cases where my patch will have negative consequences for others (removal of the tilde comparators in styles.css). I have not rigorously tested these changes. :-)

rlorenzo commented 4 years ago

Just wanted to chip in that I tried this patch on our Moodle 3.8 instance and seems to work fine for us.

gushagelberg2 commented 4 years ago

I also tried the above fix in styles.css seems to work well on my Moodle 3.8. Any news @pennedav when you guys will update the plugin? I really need your cool plugin. Seems like moodle should add these features to the Core.

neilstapleton commented 4 years ago

I also tried the above fix in styles.css seems to work well on my Moodle 3.8. Any news @pennedav when you guys will update the plugin? I really need your cool plugin. Seems like moodle should add these features to the Core.

Great that there is a patch that works out there, itching to see what your official 3.8 release will hold. Any idea on a release date would be very much appropriated.

We have a code freeze for our upgrade to 3.8 on 3rd March, so our clock is ticking really. Although v3.7-r4 + patch will get us there.

abias commented 4 years ago

Hi all,

I am sorry for the long period of silence on this issue from my side. As you know, this is a plugin which is published to the community on a volunteer basis and, once again, local requirements for other projects outplayed a quick fix of this issue for the community.

I can confirm that #50 is a working hotfix for the collapsing problem and everyone updating to 3.8 now should try it. But I have also seen that it does only fix particular symptoms instead of the root of the problem.

I have just published a last 3.7 version and am now working on finding a real solution for this issue here. This could also bring solutions to #36 and #48, but I can't promise anything at the moment.

I will keep you updated.

Cheers, Alex

abias commented 4 years ago

Well, I wrote the last post in this issue at the beginning of february. And then Covid-19 came around the corner and changed priorities quite fundamentally.

I am happy to report today that this issue has finally been resolved in https://github.com/moodleuulm/moodle-local_boostnavigation/commit/f3868412c0e65b63d419882b66b45b10cebfa46b. An official 3.8 version of this plugin will be pushed within the next few days to the Moodle plugins repo as well.

Thank you all for your patience throughout these times.

Cheers, Alex