search

moonsdust / top-songs

Characteristics of Top Songs Has Changed from Pandemic Brain: An analysis of songs on Billboard's Year-End Hot 100 singles list (2014 to 2023)
https://49z7k8-emily-su.shinyapps.io/top-songs-characteristics-app/
MIT License
0 stars 0 forks source link

Peer review #1

Closed AdrianUofT closed 6 months ago

AdrianUofT commented 7 months ago

https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/0fc7a317bc3780666cfebea95a019f29c891e7a3/paper/paper.qmd#L53-L55

If you aren't using these delete them

https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/0fc7a317bc3780666cfebea95a019f29c891e7a3/paper/paper.qmd#L110

Rewrite this part. Full sentences are preferred.

Makes no coherent sense.

https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/0fc7a317bc3780666cfebea95a019f29c891e7a3/paper/paper.qmd#L132

You already stated you used R so why are you stating it again??

https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/0fc7a317bc3780666cfebea95a019f29c891e7a3/paper/paper.qmd#L137

In particular what?

https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/0fc7a317bc3780666cfebea95a019f29c891e7a3/paper/paper.qmd#L139

???

https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/0fc7a317bc3780666cfebea95a019f29c891e7a3/paper/paper.qmd#L142

Explain your results

https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/0fc7a317bc3780666cfebea95a019f29c891e7a3/paper/paper.qmd#L513

Ok?

https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/0fc7a317bc3780666cfebea95a019f29c891e7a3/paper/paper.qmd#L521

I think it should

https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/tree/0fc7a317bc3780666cfebea95a019f29c891e7a3/other/sketches

These don't seem to represent your dataset

https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/0fc7a317bc3780666cfebea95a019f29c891e7a3/data/raw_data/raw_data.csv

???

https://tellingstorieswithdata.com/23-assessment.html#rubric-6

Good resource I think

moonsdust commented 6 months ago

Resolved.