Final Paper Peer Review - Githubissues

moonsdust / top-songs

Characteristics of Top Songs Has Changed from Pandemic Brain: An analysis of songs on Billboard's Year-End Hot 100 singles list (2014 to 2023)

https://49z7k8-emily-su.shinyapps.io/top-songs-characteristics-app/

MIT License

0 stars 0 forks source link

Final Paper Peer Review #2

Closed Diana-Guanzhi-Liu closed 6 months ago

Diana-Guanzhi-Liu commented 7 months ago

General https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/tree/030b537faa137719a2d85b2428497f58a6f6d82f/scripts

Scripts are very well done! https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/tree/030b537faa137719a2d85b2428497f58a6f6d82f/other/sketches
Sketches are good but maybe rename them to be more consistent and informative
ReadMe is great https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/030b537faa137719a2d85b2428497f58a6f6d82f/paper/casual_model.png
Move this to sketches?

Paper https://github.com/moonsdust/top-songs/blob/030b537faa137719a2d85b2428497f58a6f6d82f/paper/paper.qmd#L273-L309

There are two table 3 with the same caption but different numbers. Table 5 and 7 also has the same issue
Combining table 2 and 3 might be more useful for comparing their summary statistics. Table 4 and 5 as well as 6&7 could also be combined for this purpose

moonsdust commented 6 months ago

Resolved