Peer Review Round 2 - Githubissues

moonsdust / top-songs

Characteristics of Top Songs Has Changed from Pandemic Brain: An analysis of songs on Billboard's Year-End Hot 100 singles list (2014 to 2023)

https://49z7k8-emily-su.shinyapps.io/top-songs-characteristics-app/

MIT License

0 stars 0 forks source link

Peer Review Round 2 #5

Closed SachinChhikara closed 6 months ago

SachinChhikara commented 6 months ago

Overall:

delete the datasheet from the repo
put a link to your shiny app in the your README.md

Paper:

Abstract: Informative and just the right length.

Introduction:

Who is Ghaffari et al?
Same with the other people you mention
Remove the TODO

Data:

Remove TODO
Finish the Variables of Interest section

Model: Good job, this section is well done.

Result:

remove [To finish]
a lot of graphs in this section , so them can remove
make sure to complete this section

Discussion:

section is incomplete, make sure to complete it

Overall, an interesting idea for a paper, the section that are complete look good but make sure to finish up the incomplete sections.

moonsdust commented 6 months ago

Resolved