mozilla-lockwise / lockbox-extension

Experimental Firefox extension for login management experiences, not being actively developed
Mozilla Public License 2.0
127 stars 26 forks source link

Collect website category #350

Open sandysage opened 6 years ago

sandysage commented 6 years ago

As a product manager, I want to better understand how people use Lockbox so we can better design the solution around user need.

jawz101 commented 6 years ago

Can you be more specific? I can give you an idea of what sites I would store if I did use a pw manager. I have about 230+ sites stored in my current one :/ If you're talking about having predefined categories, the one I use lets the user create their own categorization. I can't say I would recommend having predefined categories of sites because I can't say even mine feel right.

Career, Entertainment, Financial, Interweb, Shopping, Social, Tech, Work

Career - job sites Entertainment - travel sites, your Netflix's and Hulu's and stuff Financial - banking and investments Interweb - random sites, email accounts, etc. Shopping - shopping sites Social - social networks Tech - tons of user forums and tech sites Work - sites just work-related. LIke, if I changed employers I would probably scrap most of them

Looking across all of the folders and what's in them there's so much ambiguity where to put them. Should I put my electric company site here or there? How about the public library site? Does Carnival Cruiselines go under Shopping, Entertainment, or should there be a separate Travel folder? Should Walgreens be under shopping or a Health folder if I also use them for a pharmacy?

I'm used to where they are (sort of) as is. If someone else grouped them I would probably be lost. In the end, they probably don't even need folders/categories or let users make their own. It's really a personal opinion, in my mind. And I'm not a fan of tag searching but that's just my opinion. I just like a folder hierarchy I can manage myself.

It's like - my folder structure may have a bloated tech folder because I think everything is technology whereas you may have a bunch that end up in an Entertainment bucket... so either of us may want to break that up a little more with subfolders or more parent folders to have a good balance of sites within each.

jimporter commented 6 years ago

I'm pretty sure this bug is about collecting telemetry data, not about anything user-visible.