mozilla-mobile / FirefoxLite

Emerging Market Experiment
Mozilla Public License 2.0
282 stars 95 forks source link

When downloading files, sometimes the file's format is changed to ".bin" #5296

Closed youwenliang closed 4 years ago

youwenliang commented 4 years ago

Describe the bug Sometimes some file types that are downloaded change the format of the extension (like from .mkv to .bin.). There is no access to change the storage area.

Reproduce rate How many times you can reproduce such issue, given the testing rounds Not sure

Additional context

cnevinc commented 4 years ago

We'll need a reproduce step. And we'll also need to know the impact of this behavior. What's causing the problem?

cnevinc commented 4 years ago

Tested on my device. Reproduce Step:

cause: Android DownloadManager automatically adds bin as the extension to the file without a file extension.

action item

youwenliang commented 4 years ago

@cnevinc is it possible that we just don't add the .bin even if there's no extension to the files?

youwenliang commented 4 years ago

I also encounter another issue, when the download started, it will show Unknown (Pending...) on the Download Panel, look like broken to me, but still download successfully after a while.

image

cnevinc commented 4 years ago

I also encounter another issue, when the download started, it will show Unknown (Pending...) on the Download Panel, look like broken to me, but still download successfully after a while.

Please create another issue for this new issue

cnevinc commented 4 years ago

dd the .bin even if there's no extension to the file

this is doable. Just not sure what's the impact and what issue we want to solve here.

youwenliang commented 4 years ago

Just to resolve confusion from the users and divert the source of the problem to the file servers, not to the browser.

Feedback from the users related to the "bin" issue: Screenshot_2020-07-30 Reviews - Firefox Lite — Fast and Lightweight Web Browser - Google Play Console

cnevinc commented 4 years ago

on it