mozilla / connected-devices-experiments

INACTIVE - http://mzl.la/ghe-archive - A place to publish experiments and investigations from the Connected Devices team
10 stars 6 forks source link

Belkin WeMo Switch Review #5

Closed rwood-moz closed 8 years ago

rwood-moz commented 8 years ago

Belkin WeMo Switch

As part of our IOT research I decided to try out the WeMo Switch from Belkin. The WeMo switch plugs into any power outlet, and provides one single power outlet that can be controlled via WiFi. This is the switch that I purchased: http://www.belkin.com/us/F7C027-Belkin/p/P-F7C027/

Cost

For a small piece of technology it is relatively expensive. A single WeMo power switch here in Canada costs $49.99. There is a smaller more attractive model, the WeMo insight, but that costs even more ($59.99 in Canada).

Setup

Initial setup was really easy and only took a few minutes, using the following steps:

I thought it was really cool that the WeMo switch was ready to use right out of the box, and the best part was it didn't have to be registered online; I didn't need to create an account on the manufacturers cloud or anything; and I didn't have to provide any personal information besides the WiFi network info.

Usage

Just start the WeMo app and the switch appears in the list of you WeMo devices. Beside the switch (showing the name that you configured it with) there's a power button; tap the power button on the app and the switch power is turned on. Once turned on the switch icon turns green to indicate the power is on. Tap it again to turn it off and the button turns red. In my case, I could easily turn the lamp on my desk on and off with a tap of the button on the mobile app.

With the setup I used, my phone had to always be on the same WiFi network as the WeMo switch. Apparently there is a way to configure the switch so you can control it from anywhere on the internet and not just while you're on the same WiFi network, however I didn't try that out. Also the switch is compatible with IFTTT which means you can setup automation rules, like turning on the power switch at a certain time of day, or sending a text to control the switch, etc. I didn't try those features.

Issues

Generally the switch worked great however I did see the following issues now and then:

Summary

Cool product and easy to setup. I could see it being useful if you want to control one or two power outlets in your home; however due to cost I personally probably wouldn't invest in buying a large number of these devices.

robmacd8 commented 8 years ago

Great summary. I use the Belkin WeMo switch and light bulbs remotely. Generally it works well but about 20% of the time it doesn't detect all the devices. I think this may be related to the range of wi-fi in the house because it tends to be the devices that are furthest away from the router.

That said, even when the device isn't detectable, it still operates on the schedule I originally applied. The lights turn on and off at the right time consistently even without the network connection... which gives me a bit more peace of mind.