Open DamienCassou opened 7 months ago
cc @mkaply
I like this idea. However, there are a few things to consider:
There might be other concerns but that's what came to my mind at the moment.
Firefox policies are only created on first run of a Firefox profile
I just experimented with this. I think containers are populated from policies if the containers.json file doesn't exist in the profile directory yet. This is a problem I think: a company should be able to deploy an updated policy with new containers for example.
Another problem I see is that containers.json assign an ID to each container but the policies do not. This is a problem for add-ons which rely on container IDs, e.g., Cookie-AutoDelete.
Is there some room to change how policies affect this add-on or is it forged in stone? I'm thinking about something like this for policies:
{
"policies": {
"Containers": {
"LockCreate": true,
"LockDelete": true,
"Default": [
{
"id": 1,
"name": "My container",
"icon": "pet",
"color": "turquoise"
"domains": ["example.org"],
"lockDomains": true
}
]
}
}
}
Changes based on existing policies:
I kept the lower case property names in each container (e.g., "name" instead of "Name") but it seems like "Containers" is the only policy not using upper camel case.
Until have evidence that lots of companies are using containers, I'm not inclined to put a ton of work into this. The ID and domains make sense if we can do it, but the other changes would be quite a bit of work.
Before submitting a bug report
Step to reproduce
It is possible to specify containers through policies: this is documented at https://mozilla.github.io/policy-templates/#containers and looks like the following in policy.json:
This is great. Unfortunately, there is no way to (pre-)assign domains to these containers. I would like to write something like the following:
With such a configuration, opening example.org would be automatically done in the "My container" container without requiring manual configuration by each user.
Actual behavior
There is no way to associate a domain to a given container.
Expected behavior
example.org should be attached to "My container" without requiring the user to click "Always open this site in"
Additional informations
This was requested in https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/issues/2565.
Provide a copy of Troubleshooting Information page (optional)
No response