Overlay Modal Instead of Two-Step Pages

mozilla / seasponge

:pineapple: SeaSponge is an accessible threat modelling tool from Mozilla

http://mozilla.github.io/seasponge/

Mozilla Public License 2.0

275 stars 63 forks source link

Overlay Modal Instead of Two-Step Pages #29

Closed MatKallada closed 9 years ago

MatKallada commented 9 years ago

It is more intuitive for the user to have an overlay modal with "New" & "Load" when starting the application instead of travelling on two different pages.

Consider how draw.io does it

Frozenfire92 commented 9 years ago

If going this route I propose somewhere we include a Seasponge header so users will know where they are.

I like how draw.io does it but the problem is if a user didn't know where they were there is no explicit indication they are on draw.io or a drawing application

MatKallada commented 9 years ago

I like how draw.io does it but the problem is if a user didn't know where they were there is no explicit indication they are on draw.io or a drawing application

We could have a SeaSponge header on the modal.

I am aiming to have this as a one-page web-app.

Frozenfire92 commented 9 years ago

I think the one page feel is a good way to go :+1: so long as we keep the user in the loop about where they are and where they can get help and more information :)

MatKallada commented 9 years ago

we keep the user in the loop about where they are

Our application should (and will) be intuitive enough such that the user knows where they are without needing to be told explicitly.

Frozenfire92 commented 9 years ago

As discussed during the meeting today:

Mozilla found people generally don't like modals
Mozilla has removed all but 1 modal in Firefox
People may not want to load the application if they get there by mistake (performance)

MatKallada commented 9 years ago

Mozilla found people generally don't like modals

Good to know, but was there any particular mentioned reason why? Going through two separate pages for a web-app feels clunky, I feel that the modal would have coped with sentiment.

Mozilla has removed all but 1 modal in Firefox

Which modal did they keep? I find modals to be a great UX pattern, but if we are restricting ourselves from them, it would be good to know to what degree.