Closed mrheinen closed 1 month ago
Preparing PR description...
Preparing review...
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Error Handling The error returned from `s.rateLimiter.AllowRequest(sReq)` is used in the `Details` field of the new IP event, but it's not checked for nil before using `err.Error()`. This could potentially cause a panic if `err` is nil. Unused Variable The `customHeaderTmp` variable is assigned but never used. This could be a leftover from the previous implementation or an oversight. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Error handling |
Add error handling for the AddEvent operation___ **Consider adding error handling for theAddEvent call. If the operation fails, it's important to log the error or take appropriate action.** [pkg/backend/backend.go [620-626]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/33/files#diff-c65bcfe9bb457434c3e69ba3f0576d7669935f350d24e2c2c58b05b4f9c510b2R620-R626) ```diff -s.ipEventManager.AddEvent(&database.IpEvent{ +if err := s.ipEventManager.AddEvent(&database.IpEvent{ IP: sReq.SourceIP, Type: constants.IpEventRateLimited, Details: err.Error(), Source: constants.IpEventSourceBackend, HoneypotIP: sReq.HoneypotIP, -}) +}); err != nil { + // Log the error or handle it appropriately + s.logger.Error("Failed to add rate limit event", "error", err) +} ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Error handling is crucial for robust code. The suggestion correctly identifies a potential issue and provides a solution to improve reliability. | 8 |
Enhancement |
Use array join method for string concatenation___ **Consider usingjoin() method instead of manual string concatenation for better readability and performance when joining headers.** [ui/src/components/container/ContentForm.vue [383-390]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/33/files#diff-9b268cc1c4742f937010b6345e94bb8445f5bdb2238dfdc27d660c8cd000dcd3R383-R390) ```diff -var customHeaderTmp = ""; if (this.localContent.headers) { - var prefix = ""; - this.localContent.headers.forEach((header) => { - customHeaderTmp += prefix + header; - prefix = "\n"; - }); - this.customHeaders = customHeaderTmp; + this.customHeaders = this.localContent.headers.join("\n"); } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: The suggestion offers a more concise and potentially more efficient way to concatenate strings, improving code readability and possibly performance. | 6 |
Best practice |
Use unsigned integer type for count field___ **Consider using a more specific type for theCount field in the IpEvent struct. Since it represents a count, it should never be negative, so using uint64 instead of int64 would be more appropriate.** [pkg/database/database.go [247]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/33/files#diff-1adb887d06a44193c36fc1c5708be385f3129cd59c2f2aa555faa065941ed877R247-R247) ```diff -Count int64 `ksql:"count" json:"count" doc:"How often this event was seen"` +Count uint64 `ksql:"count" json:"count" doc:"How often this event was seen"` ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: Using uint64 for a count field is a good practice as counts are never negative. However, this change might require updates in other parts of the codebase and database schema. | 5 |
Use a configurable time zone instead of hardcoding UTC___ **Consider using a constant or configuration value for the UTC time zone instead ofhardcoding it. This would make the code more flexible if time zone requirements change in the future.** [pkg/analysis/ip.go [189]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/33/files#diff-24480f2fb374402d21f92840858fefced2bab4fd547efd664c76acbce047103bR189-R189) ```diff -evt.FirstSeenAt = time.Now().UTC() +evt.FirstSeenAt = time.Now().In(config.TimeZone) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 4Why: While using a configurable time zone could increase flexibility, UTC is a standard for storing timestamps and changing it might introduce complexity without clear benefits. | 4 |
PR Type
Enhancement, Bug fix
Description
FirstSeenAt
field to theIpEvent
struct and database table to track when an event was first observed.IpEventRateLimited
for rate-limited events.first_seen_at
column.Changes walkthrough ๐
6 files
ip.go
Add FirstSeenAt field to IP events
pkg/analysis/ip.go
FirstSeenAt
field toIpEvent
struct, set to current UTC timewhen processing a new event.
backend.go
Implement rate-limited event logging
pkg/backend/backend.go
is not allowed by the rate limiter.
database.go
Add FirstSeenAt field to IpEvent struct
pkg/database/database.go
FirstSeenAt
field toIpEvent
struct.FirstSeenAt
field.shared_constants.go
Add constant for rate-limited events
pkg/util/constants/shared_constants.go - Added new constant `IpEventRateLimited` with value "RATELIMITED".
EventsList.vue
Add FirstSeenAt to IP events UI
ui/src/components/container/EventsList.vue
first_seen_at
field.database.sql
Update database schema for rate-limited events
config/database.sql
first_seen_at
column toip_event
table.1 files
backend_test.go
Add tests for rate-limited events
pkg/backend/backend_test.go - Added test cases to verify the creation of rate-limited IP events.
1 files
ratelimit.go
Minor code cleanup
pkg/backend/ratelimit/ratelimit.go - Removed an empty comment line.
1 files
ContentForm.vue
Fix header formatting in ContentForm
ui/src/components/container/ContentForm.vue - Modified header concatenation logic to avoid trailing newline.