Closed mrheinen closed 3 weeks ago
Failed to generate code suggestions for PR
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ Security concerns Sensitive information exposure: The backend-config.yaml file contains an API key (AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA) which, although likely a placeholder, demonstrates that API keys are stored in plaintext in configuration files. This practice could lead to accidental exposure of sensitive credentials if not properly managed. |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Possible Bug The getResponderData method doesn't handle the case where s.llmResponder is nil, which could lead to a nil pointer dereference. Error Handling The Complete method doesn't handle context cancellation errors explicitly, which could lead to unclear error messages. Security Concern The Respond method doesn't sanitize or validate the promptInput, which could potentially lead to injection attacks if not handled properly elsewhere. |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible issue |
Add error handling for the case of no choices in the API response___ **Consider adding error handling for the case where the API response doesn't containany choices. This will prevent a potential panic if the API returns an unexpected response format.** [pkg/llm/llm.go [139-143]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-e005b1818731f04d8ccacb709416325ca76fe22743ff53ef198845c428640cc6R139-R143) ```diff if err != nil { return "", fmt.Errorf("ChatCompletion error: %v", err) } +if len(resp.Choices) == 0 { + return "", fmt.Errorf("no choices returned from API") +} + return resp.Choices[0].Message.Content, nil ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion addresses a potential panic scenario, significantly improving the robustness and reliability of the API interaction. | 9 |
Security |
Use cryptographically secure random number generation for improved security___ **Consider using a cryptographically secure random number generator instead ofmath/rand for generating random strings. This will improve the security of the generated strings, which may be important depending on their usage.** [pkg/util/general.go [60-68]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-0664544a48f58f335cd90e8a9bd6e8e5a60d8291eef87c17903fc32de04025eeR60-R68) ```diff +import "crypto/rand" + const printableChars = "0123456789abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyzABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ!\"#$%&'()*+,-./:;<=>?@[\\]^_`{|}~" func GenerateRandomString(length int) string { result := make([]byte, length) for i := 0; i < length; i++ { - result[i] = printableChars[rand.Intn(len(printableChars))] + n, err := rand.Int(rand.Reader, big.NewInt(int64(len(printableChars)))) + if err != nil { + panic(err) + } + result[i] = printableChars[n.Int64()] } return string(result) } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Replacing math/rand with crypto/rand for generating random strings is a crucial security improvement. This change significantly enhances the unpredictability of generated strings, which is essential for many security-related applications. | 9 |
Use environment variables for sensitive information___ **Consider using environment variables or a secure secret management system for theAPI key instead of hardcoding it in the configuration file. This improves security by keeping sensitive information out of the codebase.** [config/backend-config.yaml [91]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-422f5c2c60abdac2feda6fca8b0816bb571e902de5d73a2c5c9c430406dff9c5R91-R91) ```diff -api_key: AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA +api_key: ${LLM_API_KEY} ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion significantly improves security by preventing hardcoded API keys in the configuration file. It's a crucial best practice for handling sensitive information. | 9 | |
Enhancement |
Add context parameter to the Complete method for better request cancellation and timeout handling___ **Consider adding a context parameter to theComplete method to allow for request cancellation and timeout handling at the caller's discretion. This will provide more flexibility in managing long-running LLM requests.** [pkg/llm/llm_manager.go [44-51]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-079422eef64450f8a3d97a65b202d2a89a3850d6dd9282c9a8f930bd3731c26aR44-R51) ```diff -func (l *LLMManager) Complete(prompt string) (string, error) { +func (l *LLMManager) Complete(ctx context.Context, prompt string) (string, error) { entry, err := l.pCache.Get(prompt) if err == nil { return *entry, nil } - ctx, cancel := context.WithTimeout(context.Background(), l.completionTimeout) + ctx, cancel := context.WithTimeout(ctx, l.completionTimeout) defer cancel() ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion significantly improves the flexibility and control over LLM requests, allowing for better resource management and responsiveness. It's a valuable enhancement for handling long-running operations. | 8 |
Add a fallback return in the default case of the switch statement for unknown decoder types___ **Consider using a switch statement instead of multiple if-else conditions for theResponderDecoder types. This would make the code more readable and easier to maintain, especially if more decoder types are added in the future.** [pkg/backend/backend.go [620-632]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-c65bcfe9bb457434c3e69ba3f0576d7669935f350d24e2c2c58b05b4f9c510b2R620-R632) ```diff switch rule.ResponderDecoder { case constants.ResponderDecoderTypeNone: final_match = match[1] case constants.ResponderDecoderTypeUri: final_match = decoding.DecodeURLOrEmptyString(match[1], true) if final_match == "" { slog.Error("could not decode URI", slog.String("match", match[1])) } case constants.ResponderDecoderTypeHtml: final_match = decoding.DecodeHTML(match[1]) default: slog.Error("unknown responder decoder", slog.String("decoder", rule.ResponderDecoder)) + return strings.Replace(string(content.Data), responder.LLMReplacementTag, responder.LLMReplacementFallbackString, 1) } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion improves error handling by providing a fallback response for unknown decoder types, enhancing the robustness of the code. | 7 | |
Add a configuration option for maximum token limit___ **Consider adding a configuration option for the maximum token limit or responselength for the LLM. This can help control resource usage and prevent excessively long responses.** [config/backend-config.yaml [94-95]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-422f5c2c60abdac2feda6fca8b0816bb571e902de5d73a2c5c9c430406dff9c5R94-R95) ```diff # How long a completion is allowed to take. llm_completion_timeout: 60s +# Maximum number of tokens in the LLM response. +llm_max_tokens: 1000 ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion enhances resource management and control over LLM responses. It's a valuable addition for optimizing performance and preventing potential issues with excessively long responses. | 7 | |
Improve command-line argument parsing and help message generation___ **Consider using a more robust flag parsing library likepflag or cobra for better command-line argument handling and help message generation. This will make it easier to add new flags in the future and provide better user experience.** [cmd/llm/main.go [39-43]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-733501c64048a9c28435343cfa138c8892120de440b9febe8d0d24d320a5690bR39-R43) ```diff -flag.Parse() +pflag.Parse() if *apiKey == "" || *query == "" { - fmt.Printf("Usage: %s -api-key Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: The suggestion to use a more robust flag parsing library like `pflag` or `cobra` is valid and can improve the command-line interface. However, the current implementation is functional for a simple tool, so the impact is moderate. | 6 | |
Add a configuration option for the LLM model name___ **Add a configuration option for the LLM model name or version. This allows for easierswitching between different models or versions without changing the code.** [config/backend-config.yaml [88-90]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-422f5c2c60abdac2feda6fca8b0816bb571e902de5d73a2c5c9c430406dff9c5R88-R90) ```diff # API location. Note that the implementation was tested with Gemma 2 27b and # is not guaranteed to work with other versions or other LLMs. api_location: http://localhost:8000/v1 +# LLM model name or version +llm_model: "gemma-2-27b" ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: This suggestion improves flexibility by allowing easy switching between different LLM models or versions. It's a useful enhancement for configuration management and future-proofing the system. | 6 | |
Best practice |
Add a timeout to the context for the API call to prevent potential hanging___ **Consider adding a timeout to the context passed to the CreateChatCompletion method.This will help prevent the API call from hanging indefinitely if there's a network issue or if the OpenAI service is slow to respond.** [pkg/llm/llm.go [126-137]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-e005b1818731f04d8ccacb709416325ca76fe22743ff53ef198845c428640cc6R126-R137) ```diff +ctx, cancel := context.WithTimeout(ctx, 30*time.Second) +defer cancel() resp, err := l.client.CreateChatCompletion( ctx, openai.ChatCompletionRequest{ Model: l.model, Messages: []openai.ChatCompletionMessage{ { Role: openai.ChatMessageRoleUser, Content: fmt.Sprintf(l.promptTemplate, prompt), }, }, }, ) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding a timeout is a crucial improvement for API calls, preventing potential indefinite waits and improving the overall reliability of the system. | 8 |
Add a warning about risks and ethical considerations___ **Add a warning about the potential risks and ethical considerations of usingAI-generated responses in a honeypot system. This helps users understand the implications and use the feature responsibly.** [README.md [124]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-b335630551682c19a781afebcf4d07bf978fb1f8ac04c6bf87428ed5106870f5R124-R124) ```diff -NOTE: this is a very experimental feature. +NOTE: This is a very experimental feature. Be aware of potential risks and ethical considerations when using AI-generated responses in a honeypot system. Use responsibly and in compliance with applicable laws and regulations. ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion is important as it raises awareness about potential risks and ethical implications of using AI-generated responses in a honeypot system, which is crucial for responsible use of the feature. | 8 | |
Error handling |
Improve error handling for invalid responder types___ **Consider adding error handling for invalidresType values earlier in the function. This will prevent unnecessary processing and provide clearer error messages.** [pkg/backend/responder/llm_responder.go [26-35]](https://github.com/mrheinen/lophiid/pull/52/files#diff-c3e93e5adb1e4d4cdb55ce0b82481329eb36fe0db2b23559380252ff22c5969dR26-R35) ```diff var basePrompt string switch resType { case constants.ResponderTypeCommandInjection: basePrompt = commandInjectionPrompt case constants.ResponderTypeSourceCodeExecution: basePrompt = sourceCodeExecutionPrompt - default: return "", fmt.Errorf("invalid responder type: %s", resType) } +if basePrompt == "" { + return "", fmt.Errorf("no prompt defined for responder type: %s", resType) +} + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion enhances error handling by checking for empty prompts, which can prevent potential issues later in the execution. This improvement adds robustness to the code and can help with debugging. | 7 |
๐ก Need additional feedback ? start a PR chat
PR Type
Enhancement, Documentation
Description
This PR introduces AI/LLM integration to Lophiid, enhancing its ability to generate more realistic and dynamic responses to attacks. Key changes include:
This enhancement aims to improve Lophiid's ability to interact with attackers by providing more convincing and context-aware responses, particularly for command injection and source code execution scenarios.
Changes walkthrough ๐
23 files
api_server.go
Update JavaScript runner initialization
cmd/api/api_server.go
nil
to theNewGojaJavascriptRunner
function callbackend_main.go
Integrate LLM responder in backend
cmd/backend/backend_main.go
main.go
Add LLM testing utility
cmd/llm/main.go
server.go
Add responder regex validation
pkg/api/server.go - Added validation for responder regex in content rule updates
backend.go
Integrate LLM responder in backend server
pkg/backend/backend.go
base64_extractor.go
Update import for decoding utilities
pkg/backend/extractors/base64_extractor.go - Updated import path for decoding utilities
extractors.go
Move decoding functions to separate package
pkg/backend/extractors/extractors.go - Removed decoding functions, moving them to a separate package
nc_extractor.go
Update import for decoding utilities
pkg/backend/extractors/nc_extractor.go - Updated import path for decoding utilities
tcp_extractor.go
Update import for decoding utilities
pkg/backend/extractors/tcp_extractor.go - Updated import path for decoding utilities
unicode_extractor.go
Update import for decoding utilities
pkg/backend/extractors/unicode_extractor.go - Updated import path for decoding utilities
url_extractor.go
Update import for decoding utilities
pkg/backend/extractors/url_extractor.go - Updated import path for decoding utilities
llm_prompts.go
Add LLM prompts for responders
pkg/backend/responder/llm_prompts.go
execution
llm_responder.go
Implement LLM responder
pkg/backend/responder/llm_responder.go - Implemented LLMResponder struct and methods for LLM integration
responder.go
Define responder interface and constants
pkg/backend/responder/responder.go
database.go
Update ContentRule struct for LLM responder
pkg/database/database.go
encoding.go
Add URI and HTML decoding methods
pkg/javascript/encoding.go - Added URI and HTML decoding methods to the Encoding struct
goja.go
Integrate LLM responder in JavaScript runner
pkg/javascript/goja.go
wrappers.go
Add responder wrapper for JavaScript
pkg/javascript/wrappers.go
shared_constants.go
Add responder and decoder type constants
pkg/util/constants/shared_constants.go - Added constants for responder types and decoder types
decoding.go
Move and enhance decoding utilities
pkg/util/decoding/decoding.go
utilities
general.go
Add random string generation utility
pkg/util/general.go - Added GenerateRandomString function for creating random strings
RuleForm.vue
Update rule form with responder fields
ui/src/components/container/RuleForm.vue
decoder
database.sql
Update database schema for responder support
config/database.sql
11 files
config.go
Add LLM responder configuration
pkg/backend/config.go - Added Responder configuration struct with LLM-related settings
Config.js
Add responder configuration options
ui/src/Config.js - Added ruleResponderTypes and ruleResponderDecoders arrays
BUILD.bazel
Update Bazel build for backend
cmd/backend/BUILD.bazel - Added new dependencies for responder and LLM packages
BUILD.bazel
Add Bazel build for LLM tool
cmd/llm/BUILD.bazel - Added new Bazel build file for LLM command-line tool
backend-config.yaml
Add LLM responder configuration
config/backend-config.yaml - Added responder configuration section with LLM-related settings
BUILD.bazel
Update Bazel build for backend package
pkg/backend/BUILD.bazel - Added new dependencies for responder and decoding packages
BUILD.bazel
Update Bazel build for extractors
pkg/backend/extractors/BUILD.bazel - Updated dependencies and test files
BUILD.bazel
Add Bazel build for responder package
pkg/backend/responder/BUILD.bazel - Added new Bazel build file for responder package
BUILD.bazel
Update Bazel build for JavaScript package
pkg/javascript/BUILD.bazel - Added new dependencies for responder and decoding packages
BUILD.bazel
Add Bazel build for LLM package
pkg/llm/BUILD.bazel - Added new Bazel build file for LLM package
BUILD.bazel
Add Bazel build for decoding package
pkg/util/decoding/BUILD.bazel - Added new Bazel build file for decoding package
1 files
metrics.go
Remove comment
pkg/backend/metrics.go - Removed unnecessary comment
2 files
goja_test.go
Update tests for LLM responder integration
pkg/javascript/goja_test.go
initialization
decoding_test.go
Update decoding tests
pkg/util/decoding/decoding_test.go - Updated package name and imports for decoding tests
4 files
AI.md
Add AI integration documentation
AI.md
implementation details
README.md
Update README with AI integration information
README.md
SCRIPTING.md
Update scripting documentation with new features
SCRIPTING.md
html.decode
SEARCH_KEYWORDS.md
Add new search keywords for responder fields
SEARCH_KEYWORDS.md
responder_regex
3 files
deps.bzl
Add go-openai dependency
deps.bzl - Added go-openai dependency
go.mod
Add go-openai dependency
go.mod - Added go-openai dependency
go.sum
Update dependency checksums
go.sum - Added go-openai dependency checksums